Re:Garry Kasparov: The Last Revolutionary Technology Was The...
by rozim on Wednesday November 03, 2010 @02:10AM
(#1863880)
I think Kasparov disagrees with you via "...working hard is also part of an individual’s talent"
though to be fair he follows with
"I think working hard is sometimes just as important to having a talent."
Re:Garry Kasparov: The Last Revolutionary Technology Was The...
by fjh on Wednesday November 03, 2010 @10:37AM
(#1864899)
You don't only lack the evidence, I think it is fair to say that the evidence contradicts your opinion. If you look at people like Judit Polgár, it seems like practice is far more important than any kind of intrinsic ability.
Pushing beyond that and into the Super to Elite Grandmaster range (2550-2800) requires extraordinary levels of memory, concentration, calculation and pattern matching. Levels that can't be instilled in someone through any amount of training. A person either possesses them or (s)he doesn't.
I lack the evidence at hand, but I'm certain I've seen it before that aptitude in those areas correlates strongly to high intelligence.