It's the "Penis Craig's list Effect" (Credit: Ramit Sethi). Basically you can send a picture of your penis (resume) and sound like a desperate creeper(cover letter) to 100 women on crags list. Or you can figure out what you think 2-3 women actually want and write something specifically for them.
Funded tech companies probably won't pass up a proactive, solid programmer that shows some competency through a blog, side projects, weekend projects, etc, etc.
I feel fortunate to be in Baltimore and part of our local Rails group (monthly pub nights) and our hackerspace (total playground) because I've met people at numerous other tech companies and if I ever want to go looking for a job I know I have a network to call upon.
Go live it!
Statistically they are, unless it's an exceptional company, but that's really just cargo cult rationalization at that point. You don't reliably get into great companies by going through monster.com
>I'd be down to do it your way if there were an easy way to browse through interesting tech-related companies in NYC, that I know are hiring.
I think you're missing the point. The point is to stop being a consumer and instead be a part of the scene and breathe what's going on in the industry. You should know what the great companies in your area of preference/expertise are before you ever need a job.
I like your proactive approach very much, but the search space (all companies in my region) seems rather large. With job listings, I at least know they are hiring, what technologies they use, and what's expected of the role. I'd be down to do it your way if there were an easy way to browse through interesting tech-related companies in NYC, that I know are hiring.