News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla Autopilot and Euro NCAP by Someone1234 on Friday December 07, 2018 @11:24AM (#18628949)
Planes can land entirely on autopilot.

Just requires the airport to have ILS, and a fairly modern autopilot.

Re:Tesla Autopilot and Euro NCAP by mazugrin on Friday December 07, 2018 @11:42AM (#18629117)
The problem is that most people don't understand what the term "autopilot" refers to. In airplanes, autopilot can safely control the aircraft in a limited set of circumstances. It can't control the aircraft on the ground, nor can it control the aircraft during takeoff. And it can only land the aircraft on certain types of runways. Crucially, it requires human pilots to be monitoring the progress of the aircraft at all times because there are many situations that can arise while the system is engaged that require a corrective response. This seems to be no different from the Tesla system. Of course, due to the nature of driving on a crowded road versus being up in a relatively empty sky, there's a significant difference in the time available to apply these corrective responses.
Re:Tesla Autopilot and Euro NCAP by dingaling on Friday December 07, 2018 @12:07PM (#18629349)
Autopilots can in practice control ground manoeuvres, and take-off. That was demonstrated in the 1970s. There simply isn't the commercial impetus to push them to certification; it's cheaper for an airline to cancel a flight than to maintain such a technical capability, mainly due to paperwork.
Re:Tesla Autopilot and Euro NCAP by mikeash on Friday December 07, 2018 @11:42AM (#18629121)
Some can. Airplane autopilots are tremendously varied. Some are as simple as a gyroscope hooked up to the ailerons to keep the wings level. I’m always baffled as to why people think “autopilot” implies any sort of autonomy.
Re:Tesla Autopilot and Euro NCAP by Someone1234 on Friday December 07, 2018 @11:51AM (#18629205)
> I’m always baffled as to why people think “autopilot” implies any sort of autonomy.

It is literally in the name.

Re:Tesla Autopilot and Euro NCAP by mikeash on Friday December 07, 2018 @11:53AM (#18629224)
“Auto” just means “self.” Do autobiographies write themselves? Does the word “automobile” imply no driver is needed?
Re:Tesla Autopilot and Euro NCAP by Someone1234 on Friday December 07, 2018 @12:01PM (#18629297)
It doesn't "just" mean that. You aren't arguing in good faith when you choose to selectively use and ignore dictionary definitions of common words as it conveniences you.
Re:Tesla Autopilot and Euro NCAP by simion314 on Friday December 07, 2018 @12:10PM (#18629371)
Auto can mean also automatic, autonomous , you are trying to defend the meaning of autopilot by bringing aviation definition, it would be similar to me telling all the people that they are using language wrong because in chemistry or math the word X ids defined to mean something a bit different.

in physics acceleration is used when things slow down too, but at least in my language this is weird and in day to day use acceleration means increase in speed, you want to understand how/why most people define autopilot as more then dr5iver assist then just ask them and stop telling them they are wrong because in domain X the word is used different.

Re:Tesla Autopilot and Euro NCAP by mikeash on Friday December 07, 2018 @12:32PM (#18629600)
I’m not saying they’re wrong. I’m saying their understanding of the word baffles me. That’s not the same thing, and it’s kind of annoying to be attacked just for not understanding people.
Re:Tesla Autopilot and Euro NCAP by simion314 on Friday December 07, 2018 @01:10PM (#18630010)
Let me try to explain, people are not knowledgeable on how airplane autopilot works, what people understand when they hear autopilot is from what they had seen in movies or games, read in books or what the words actual mean.
Re:Tesla Autopilot and Euro NCAP by mikeash on Friday December 07, 2018 @02:15PM (#18630625)
There are contrary examples that normal people would know too. For instance, it’s common to use the phrase “on autopilot” to describe the state of a person who does something really stupid because they were following a routine without thinking.
Re:Tesla Autopilot and Euro NCAP by SmellyGeekBoy on Monday December 10, 2018 @03:46AM (#18646270)
Agreed. So "Auto Pilot" == "Self Pilot".

As in, it pilots itself. Which would indeed imply that no driver was needed.

Re:Tesla Autopilot and Euro NCAP by conscion on Friday December 07, 2018 @12:34PM (#18629626)
No but autobiographies are self-biographies, automobiles are self-mobile so an autopilot would self-pilot, i.e. pilot itself
Re:Tesla Autopilot and Euro NCAP by mikeash on Friday December 07, 2018 @12:58PM (#18629893)
And they do, but that doesn’t mean they’re autonomous or capable of handling any situation. A wing leveler is piloting itself.
Re:Tesla Autopilot and Euro NCAP by ionised on Friday December 07, 2018 @11:46AM (#18629157)
Probably because that's what the name suggests.
Re:Tesla Autopilot and Euro NCAP by leetcrew on Friday December 07, 2018 @11:55AM (#18629238)
as a Greek and Latin student, there are quite a lot of English words that don't quite mean what I would expect. if it's really important that I understand how a word is normally used in English (eg, some critical safety context), I look it up.
Re:Tesla Autopilot and Euro NCAP by simion314 on Friday December 07, 2018 @12:11PM (#18629390)
there are words and expressions well know from pop culture, like say time travel, do you need to look up some physics book to find the definition or find some experiments where they prove time travel is or not possible ?
Re:Tesla Autopilot and Euro NCAP by leetcrew on Friday December 07, 2018 @01:17PM (#18630068)
I don't usually make $40,000 decisions that depend on time travel.
Re:Tesla Autopilot and Euro NCAP by simion314 on Friday December 07, 2018 @01:44PM (#18630306)
How do you research it though? Do you read reviews, watch videos or you search online for the technical manuals with all the details before you buy ?

The reviews and videos may not contain all the details you will get in the technical manual that you don't have before you get the car.

Re:Tesla Autopilot and Euro NCAP by leetcrew on Friday December 07, 2018 @03:11PM (#18631146)
if I'm spending that much money on something I can die in, you better believe I'm reading reviews in all the major car publications (and btw, all the in depth reviews do a pretty good job explaining what you need to know about tesla autopilot), watching reviews on YouTube, seeing what owners have to say on the relevant forums, etc. If the car has some new safety feature that I don't understand, I'm definitely reading everything the manual has to say about it before I drive off the lot.

then again I'm one of those weird people who actually takes the recommended safety precautions when I do dangerous things. I also do crazy stuff like checking my tire pressure.

Re:Tesla Autopilot and Euro NCAP by mnw21cam on Friday December 07, 2018 @11:33AM (#18629044)
Yesbut. It also requires the meat-sack to be sitting in the cockpit telling the autopilot which heading/altitude/waypoint to head to next, listen to ATC instructions, input the correct ILS frequency into the system, etc. And that's when everything goes absolutely fine.
Re:Tesla Autopilot and Euro NCAP by Someone1234 on Friday December 07, 2018 @11:40AM (#18629094)
Planes can absolutely land themselves. The only point you're making is that an autopilot cannot entirely replace a pilot, but that was never in contention. The poster above claimed an autopilot cannot land, it can, and it does every single day.

Additionally ILS frequency can be automatically set via electronic charts, particularly if the flight plan contains the destination runway (which isn't always possible).

Re:Tesla Autopilot and Euro NCAP by labcomputer on Friday December 07, 2018 @01:06PM (#18629985)
> Planes can absolutely land themselves.

No. They can’t. Not unless you have a IIIc approach and autopilot. Those things are not common.

If you don’t have both of those things, the pilot must, at minimum, fly the flare (for a IIIb approach, which are somewhat common at large airports).

Even if you have a IIIc approach, the pilot still monitors systems, deploys high lift devices and landing gear, makes the go/no decision. There is no reasonable interpretation of “planes can absolutely land themselves” which is in any way true.

Re:Tesla Autopilot and Euro NCAP by SmellyGeekBoy on Monday December 10, 2018 @03:48AM (#18646276)
> No. They can’t. Not unless you have a IIIc approach and autopilot. Those things are not common.

So you're saying they can?

Re:Tesla Autopilot and Euro NCAP by Piskvorrr on Friday December 07, 2018 @11:41AM (#18629109)
Wikipedia has an accurate summary: "[in all cases a CAT III autoland requires the] flight crew to monitor the system behavior very carefully and be ready to take control immediately." Oops.
Re:Tesla Autopilot and Euro NCAP by labcomputer on Friday December 07, 2018 @12:54PM (#18629853)
Hah, “just”.

Very few airports have even one cat IIIc approach. Not all modern airliners have an autopilot capable of a IIIc approach (which requires triple redundancy, IIRC).

And you accuse others of arguing in bad faith...