News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Alphazero crushes Stockfish in 1,000 game match by sinuhe69 on Friday December 07, 2018 @07:36AM (#18627116)
I feel compelled to repeat the previous criticism on the games: - Stockfisch was never designed nor tested on so many cores. Running on 44 cores may degrade the performance of Stockfish. - Stockfish was designed to start a game with an opening book. In games with opening book, Stockfish has won significantly more games, too. - Stockfish 8 was not a particularly good implementation. Stockfish 9 or 10 should be a better choice, though.

Nevertheless, the performance of AlphaZero was impressive, especially the positional knowledge it has acquired is second none. In all existing chess engines, positional knowledge is under-represented through simple heuristics. Acquiring positional knowledge was a longtime dream of chess programmers many generations. The dream was to create an engine which plays a more human-like style of chess. AlphaZero has realized this dream and even goes beyond that: extending the humans knowledge of chess.

I believe the most intriguing question right now is why AlphaZero stopped to improve after 9 hours of training? It’s due to the inherent problem of chess or due to the limits of ANN? If it’s the latter, how we can breakthrough and create a new generation of engines that can even surpass AlphaZero?

Re:Alphazero crushes Stockfish in 1,000 game match by forgot-my-pw on Friday December 07, 2018 @11:48AM (#18629176)
Perhaps in the highest level of chess, almost all games will be a draw. So there's not much progress left to be made other than playing a variation that has less draws, like Shogi?