Re:Las Vegas Slot Machines vs Electronic Voting Machines
by eli on Tuesday November 02, 2010 @06:16PM
(#1862634)
Scary stuff, but this is from 2006 and not all of these things are still true in all places. (States like CA require access to all software used on machines, for example.)
That said, these comparisons between voting machines and ATMs or slot machines are always a bit unfair. Slot machines and ATMs carefully log and track every action that every user does on them. In a voting machine, it must be impossible to tie a vote to a specific person. This is makes it a much trickier problem to solve.
Re:Las Vegas Slot Machines vs Electronic Voting Machines
by something on Tuesday November 02, 2010 @07:18PM
(#1862853)
The problem may be tricky, but surely it's worth solving and doing so publicly. Shouldn't this be doable?
Of all the things i would like to see well-intentioned billionaires do, funding a permanent mission to perfect voting is very high on the list. what greater gift to democracy than provable integrity of its atom?
from the outside it looked irregular at least (and some of the voting practices seem very bad).
Here in Uruguay we have a very reliable manual voting mechanism... but if you want electronic, it seems Brazil did it reasonably well (didn't follow the elections that closely, but there's no contest to the voting methods), so you can copy them instead.
Not to mention in the US you don't have direct representation (for the presidential elections), and there are several shenanigans with the voting districts, so, I'd say that voting works less in the US than in several other places.
Re:Las Vegas Slot Machines vs Electronic Voting Machines
by eli on Wednesday November 03, 2010 @09:27PM
(#1867207)
The 2000 election was an ugly mess because damn near exactly as many people in Florida voted Bush as voted Gore, not because of rampant voter fraud.
Better technology could have helped, for sure, but there is always going to be some small margin of error and this particular race was decided by something under 1/100 of a percent.
Re:Las Vegas Slot Machines vs Electronic Voting Machines
by bigiain on Tuesday November 02, 2010 @10:44PM
(#1863394)
It's not jut about whether vote fraud is happening though - its also about the _perception_ of whether vote fraud _can_ happen.
I think it would be worth expending a considerable amount of resources not in the expectation of catching any fraud, but to be able to demonstrate that if there _were_ any vote fraud, there are appropriate means in place to find it.
Re:Las Vegas Slot Machines vs Electronic Voting Machines
by eli on Wednesday November 03, 2010 @09:31PM
(#1867217)
Actually, we already kinda did that. Attorney General Ashcroft made voter fraud a top priority for the Department of Justice. Yet there were very few convictions nationwide, and nearly all of them were for honest mistakes.
Re:Las Vegas Slot Machines vs Electronic Voting Machines
by something on Wednesday November 03, 2010 @10:28AM
(#1864872)
exactly. to a cynic, of which there are many in the younger population that tends not to vote in the US, "mostly works" can mean "doesn't work" (...so why bother?)
if you KNEW the system was perfect, that alone might be reason to participate.
Re:Las Vegas Slot Machines vs Electronic Voting Machines
by MichaelGG on Tuesday November 02, 2010 @10:08PM
(#1863296)
You assert that fraud is incredibly rare -- how are we to know? Did all places start issuing paper receipts that were tallied against the electronic count? Isn't part of the problem that we have no idea how bad electronic voting fraud is, be it prevalent or nonexistent?
Re:Las Vegas Slot Machines vs Electronic Voting Machines
by andyv on Tuesday November 02, 2010 @06:36PM
(#1862721)
I am sooooo glad I don't have to vote electronically. Folks here who flip bits for a living know only too well how easy this is to do. Changing a thousand paper ballots? Hard, time comsuming, messy. Changing a thousand electronic ballots? Invisible, silent, quick, untracable...
Re:Las Vegas Slot Machines vs Electronic Voting Machines
by ertyujhygfd on Tuesday November 02, 2010 @08:01PM
(#1862968)
In civilised democracies they are counted in public by lots of little old ladies while inspectors from each party, and any member of the public can watch them.
Of course this does rather reduce the drama and excitement so it might not be suitable for you chaps.
Re:Las Vegas Slot Machines vs Electronic Voting Machines
by andyv on Tuesday November 02, 2010 @07:22PM
(#1862870)
Why, electronically, of course. But (1) the original paper ballots still exist and (2) the machines that do the counting are far fewer and are in a secure location. Fraud at this level can be detected by examining a random sample of ballots. Easy to do, since all the ballots are present.
Re:Las Vegas Slot Machines vs Electronic Voting Machines
by stretchwithme on Wednesday November 03, 2010 @02:41AM
(#1863944)
I think its worth mentioning that winner-take-all elections prevent you from getting your interests represented. So this whole debate is like fiddling with the alignment of your wheels when the car's no longer on the road.
Re:Las Vegas Slot Machines vs Electronic Voting Machines
by mkramlich on Wednesday November 03, 2010 @04:50AM
(#1864202)
I voted today. A few of the issues I had to vote on had only 1 choice. (I fill-in the bubble, or, not. WTF.) Several had 2 choices, the RP candidate or the DP candidate. A few had 3-5 choices. A few had a blank line for "write in" choice. This is "democracy" in action today in the USA, folks.
Re:Las Vegas Slot Machines vs Electronic Voting Machines
by stretchwithme on Wednesday November 03, 2010 @06:19AM
(#1864349)
We need proportional representation. I'm pretty sure I'd have better choices with PR. Right now its a choice between people that don't understand economics or real life and people that don't understand economics or real life.
Re:Las Vegas Slot Machines vs Electronic Voting Machines
by stretchwithme on Wednesday November 03, 2010 @02:38AM
(#1863934)
All you need in a voting machine is something that can properly punch the cards. That's what the problem in 2000. You don't need to send the votes over the Internet or store anything on the machine. It doesn't need to be secure.
But you will need a PC that costs a couple hundred bucks. And a card punch machine that has been around for decades. In other words, commodity hardware.
Once you've made your choices and your ballot's punched, you should be able to walk it over to a completely different PC that has a punch card reader. And maybe its got software from a completely different organization. Did it record your choices properly? Confirmed. Now, drop it in the box.
Simple. No possibility for fraud and you got a paper trail.
Re:Las Vegas Slot Machines vs Electronic Voting Machines
by SkyMarshal on Wednesday November 03, 2010 @04:03AM
(#1864113)
Nit: You don't even need anachronistic punch card machines, color-in-the-bubble voting forms work just fine. Those are used in even more places than hole punch forms these days, from voting to SAT grading machines. They're even more commodity, more familiar to the public.
Re:Las Vegas Slot Machines vs Electronic Voting Machines
by stretchwithme on Monday November 08, 2010 @03:24AM
(#1881826)
yeah but using a PC lets the user see their choices clearly and encodes their vote with a single click, instead of having to relate a letter or number to their choice and find the question on the form and then confirm the letter or number before finally filling it in. Grandmothers with shaky hands will have a much easier time.
Re:Las Vegas Slot Machines vs Electronic Voting Machines
by gallerytungsten on Tuesday November 02, 2010 @09:29PM
(#1863215)
Alas, the game is rigged in DC and the state legislatures. Regulation as strong as the slot machines is likely to be applied...never, at the current rate of change. So goes the gamble of democracy.
Re:Las Vegas Slot Machines vs Electronic Voting Machines
by electromagnetic on Tuesday November 02, 2010 @08:26PM
(#1863036)
Actually I believe it's a function that older machines were specifically designed to be either unwinnable (I've seen some old slots, certain ones don't have BAR or 7 on all wheels) or for the odds to be exponentially against you.
When the laws changed and gaming was regulated casinos wanted to make sure they weren't the ones now being cheated.
That said, these comparisons between voting machines and ATMs or slot machines are always a bit unfair. Slot machines and ATMs carefully log and track every action that every user does on them. In a voting machine, it must be impossible to tie a vote to a specific person. This is makes it a much trickier problem to solve.
Of all the things i would like to see well-intentioned billionaires do, funding a permanent mission to perfect voting is very high on the list. what greater gift to democracy than provable integrity of its atom?
Really, we may be better off launching a PR campaign to remind people that voting mostly works.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_presidential_elec...
If you want something less editable than Wikipedia:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/americas/1013552.stm
from the outside it looked irregular at least (and some of the voting practices seem very bad).
Here in Uruguay we have a very reliable manual voting mechanism... but if you want electronic, it seems Brazil did it reasonably well (didn't follow the elections that closely, but there's no contest to the voting methods), so you can copy them instead.
Not to mention in the US you don't have direct representation (for the presidential elections), and there are several shenanigans with the voting districts, so, I'd say that voting works less in the US than in several other places.
Better technology could have helped, for sure, but there is always going to be some small margin of error and this particular race was decided by something under 1/100 of a percent.
I think it would be worth expending a considerable amount of resources not in the expectation of catching any fraud, but to be able to demonstrate that if there _were_ any vote fraud, there are appropriate means in place to find it.
if you KNEW the system was perfect, that alone might be reason to participate.
There's no possible technical reason why voting software isn't basically bulletproof and transparent.
Of course this does rather reduce the drama and excitement so it might not be suitable for you chaps.
But you will need a PC that costs a couple hundred bucks. And a card punch machine that has been around for decades. In other words, commodity hardware.
Once you've made your choices and your ballot's punched, you should be able to walk it over to a completely different PC that has a punch card reader. And maybe its got software from a completely different organization. Did it record your choices properly? Confirmed. Now, drop it in the box.
Simple. No possibility for fraud and you got a paper trail.
Otherwise, agreed.
Of course all these same requirements make perfect sense to implement for voting machines.
When the laws changed and gaming was regulated casinos wanted to make sure they weren't the ones now being cheated.