News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Eviation’s Alice is an all-electric, nine-person aircraft by bronco21016 on Wednesday December 05, 2018 @09:38PM (#18614908)
Interesting concept.

I’m curious what voltage the pack runs at and how long it would take to charge. Many of these types of aircraft operate in FAR Part 135 on-demand operations. Aircraft and crew utilization are crucial for the business model.

Expensive airplanes and pilots don’t make money sitting on the ground. Of course, if operating costs (fuel) are a fraction of a traditional aircraft then margins get better but do they get good enough to offset 2-3x more aircraft and pilots to operate those aircraft to be able to fulfill demand?

I hate to sound like the people who constantly naysay electric cars because of charging times but in this industry turn around time is crucial.

Re:Eviation’s Alice is an all-electric, nine-person aircraft by aphextron on Wednesday December 05, 2018 @09:54PM (#18614969)
>I’m curious what voltage the pack runs at and how long it would take to charge. Many of these types of aircraft operate in FAR Part 135 on-demand operations. Aircraft and crew utilization are crucial for the business model.

This is the number one question I had as well, for the same reasons. Porsche has a 1000V system in their new Taycan EV, so I'd assume they're at least at that level. At 900kWh, a system like that could charge from 10% (assumed minimum reserve) to 95% (Batteries are never really charged to 100%) in under 2 hours @ 400KW, which is about the power level of the beefiest EV chargers being developed right now.

More likely they will have swappable batteries, which makes a lot more sense from a thermal management point of view as well. You can either load up the pack with all kinds of cooling and deal with the added weight, or just make it passive air-cooled and swap it out between flights before it gets too hot.

Re:Eviation’s Alice is an all-electric, nine-person aircraft by technofiend on Wednesday December 05, 2018 @11:22PM (#18615385)
In my humble opinion swappable batteries on an airplane would run afoul of the maintenance regulations that require an A & P to perform and sign off on changes to the aircraft.
Re:Eviation’s Alice is an all-electric, nine-person aircraft by aphextron on Thursday December 06, 2018 @01:45AM (#18615946)
>In my humble opinion swappable batteries on an airplane would run afoul of the maintenance regulations that require an A & P to perform and sign off on changes to the aircraft.

Pipistrel Alpha, the only real production electric plane shipping, is using swappable batteries. There's really no other viable way with current technology to have reasonable recharge times.

Re:Eviation’s Alice is an all-electric, nine-person aircraft by Robotbeat on Thursday December 06, 2018 @01:32AM (#18615902)
Correct.
Re:Eviation’s Alice is an all-electric, nine-person aircraft by justin66 on Thursday December 06, 2018 @12:56PM (#18620372)
> At 900kWh, a system like that could charge from 10% (assumed minimum reserve) to 95% (Batteries are never really charged to 100%) in under 2 hours @ 400KW, which is about the power level of the beefiest EV chargers being developed right now.

There's no particular reason charging a big, multicell battery needs to bottleneck on a single charger. (is there?) It's done with cars for what I always assumed were cost and convenience reasons.

Re:Eviation’s Alice is an all-electric, nine-person aircraft by tristanb on Thursday December 06, 2018 @04:07PM (#18622252)
Re:Eviation’s Alice is an all-electric, nine-person aircraft by Robotbeat on Thursday December 06, 2018 @01:31AM (#18615898)
Will not be swappable as that would add too much weight.
Re:Eviation’s Alice is an all-electric, nine-person aircraft by taneq on Wednesday December 05, 2018 @09:52PM (#18614959)
Current electric aircraft like the Pipistrel Alpha Electro (https://www.pipistrel.si/plane/alpha-electro/overview) have swappable battery packs. I can't see why this wouldn't be an option here.
Re:Eviation’s Alice is an all-electric, nine-person aircraft by Robotbeat on Thursday December 06, 2018 @01:32AM (#18615903)
Weight.
Re:Eviation’s Alice is an all-electric, nine-person aircraft by ajross on Wednesday December 05, 2018 @11:04PM (#18615303)
> I’m curious what voltage the pack runs at and how long it would take to charge

It's surely not a new battery chemistry. Lithium cells have a voltage in the 3-3.5V range. If you want more, you put them in series. And fed with an appropriately regulated supply, all common cell types will charge to full capacity from empty in 4 hours or so, reaching 50% sometime inside of 1 hour (that is, most of the time spent is in "topping off" the thing, broadly you can get energy into a battery at least as fast as you can get it out). It's literally no different than your phone battery.

Re:Eviation’s Alice is an all-electric, nine-person aircraft by bluGill on Thursday December 06, 2018 @10:00AM (#18618496)
They are claiming a price of $3 million plus. While that sounds like a lot, from what I can tell it is cheap for aircraft of that size. (it is very hard to track down prices for new aircraft so feel free to correct me). It may well be feasible to buy 3 of these to replace 1 of something else, and have 2 charging all the time.
Re:Eviation’s Alice is an all-electric, nine-person aircraft by bronco21016 on Thursday December 06, 2018 @10:39AM (#18618897)
Alice really compares more to large turboprops rather than small jets like the HondaJet. When comparing to the used turboprops on the market the Alice isn’t really that competitive. A used Cessna Conquest with more range could be had for around $1-1.5 million depending on condition. Of course operating expenses are significantly more so someone still needs to figure out the math there.

If you’re buying a fleet of new aircraft I suppose it’s competitive but for similar price a Pilatus PC-12 gets you significantly more utility. Land just about anywhere and easily find fuel.

Another factor is these MSRP estimates are really hard to pin down before the aircraft is fully developed. In the early 2000s there was a flood of companies claiming $1 million jets. Eclipse Jet being the most notable. Most of those programs either didn’t survive or ended up charging more like $5-10 million. Getting an aircraft certified isn’t cheap and it’s really hard to get economies of scale on something so expensive.

I don’t want to completely discount the program but I keep going back to the charging when I try to flesh this idea out. The only possible way I see this succeeding is if the company also facilitates building a charging network. When I was in high school I worked at a small Midwest airport and the idea that the city, who owned the airport, would build charging infrastructure for a niche aircraft is laughable. They almost shutdown their Jet A fueling infrastructure (that they charged money for) because they claimed it was too expensive to maintain.

Overall point is that it’s doable but there are hurdles and a half baked idea and marketing fluff is going to result in yet another failed aviation venture.

Re:Eviation’s Alice is an all-electric, nine-person aircraft by Latteland on Thursday December 06, 2018 @05:52PM (#18623251)
They don't have electricity at the airport? The Tesla superchargers use regular commercial hv lines, nothing special. The additional expense for an airport that will be a new transformer. This is why Tesla is able to put chargers in so many locations, cause it doesn't cost 3 million dollars each time they do it. Dig a whole, run the power, add a transformer, pain, fill in the hole. They built one in a week nearby.
Re:Eviation’s Alice is an all-electric, nine-person aircraft by irq-1 on Thursday December 06, 2018 @12:16PM (#18619929)
> I keep going back to the charging when I try to flesh this idea out.

Could they burn jet fuel in an electric generator? Maybe not economically, but the infrastructure is there.

Re:Eviation’s Alice is an all-electric, nine-person aircraft by bluGill on Thursday December 06, 2018 @03:58PM (#18622160)
Jet fuel is basically diesel fuel without lubrication. Diesel engines will run on it. If you don't mind replacing your injectors more often than you change the oil you could go so far as say they run just fine.

I understand there are diesel aircraft engines that run on it - presumably this means that the injectors are different from all the engines I'm familiar with. You could install this engine connected to a generator and get a hybrid, though I don't know if it is a good idea. One the plus side you can put the engine where you want it for weight distribution reasons, because it is a hybrid you can always run at optimal rpm, diesel fuel has a better energy/mass ratio, and when/if it fails you have plenty battery backup so your wouldn't need as much maintenance as most aircraft engines get. On the negative side, you are paying to haul this engine around even on short flights.

Re:Eviation’s Alice is an all-electric, nine-person aircraft by lazerpants on Thursday December 06, 2018 @10:23AM (#18618694)
It's a pretty low price. The HondaJet is close at approx. $5MM, though it has more than double the claimed range of the Alice.