News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mathematically correct but psychologically wrong by mwexler on Tuesday November 02, 2010 @12:45PM (#1861191)
Am I only one who was surprised to see not one reference to any research or proof of his claim? That is, anything that shows a situation where people in, say, equal debt situations, 1/2 were given snowball, half given pay big ones first, then measure debt reduction, satisfaction, perception of accomplishment, etc? Or even just a survey? Anything?

I've heard snowball as a great approach... but without some proof, I wonder if it truly is "...a problem with an obvious but naive solution". Behavioral Economics theorizing aside, even one example from a simple survey or academic study would do much to support his overall point.

Otherwise, his "Many things that don’t look optimal are in fact optimal" comes into question, and I don't want my silly need for proof to get in the way of that essential point, which, come to think of it, I firmly believe even without much proof. But still...

Re:Mathematically correct but psychologically wrong by koepked on Tuesday November 02, 2010 @06:33PM (#1862702)
I can't offer technical proof, but the snowball method saved me. Psychologically, getting rid of the easier debts wasn't the biggest factor though. The increased cash flow from the lack of those payments allowed me to make payments on larger debts that actually felt like they were making a dent. That was an awesome feeling.