It still leaves a small window of opportunity for abuse, but seems like a decent middle ground.
My personal solution is to not drive often, and when I do it's a 1996 Subaru. ;)
But, he may be saying he's vulnerable for long periods because the idle timer won't kick in for him.
I'd much rather have a solution that precludes relaying; maybe something that involves a precise turnaround time in the radio signal between the car and key, and so the key physically can't work beyond some relatively short range.
We should just go back to traditional keys if this is the case.
I want key holes in all doors. I want to insert a key to start the car.
I'm not sure if it's been from rust, lack of use + time, or ice, but unused or backup keyholes on vehicles seem to fail far more often than those used for normal entry.
"I'm lucky" is not quite the same as "that's a nonexistent problem".
Source: worked for a valet company
As well as taking away much of the convenience advantage that passive fobs have over active-only fobs (most fobs already can be actively used, as well as passively.)