The confusion stems from the language you used in your comment, which made it seem like you were claiming a lot more than you actually turned out to be:
"I have yet to see anyone ... actually do the experiment to determine where the actual breakeven point is. Hint: it's less than 5000."
The fact of the matter is that hash tables are faster than ALists in all but the most trivial of cases. Theory predicts it, and an experiment that takes all of two minutes to do confirms it. Everything else is quibbling over angels on the head of a pin.
I'm struggling to think of a non-trolling motivation that explains this behavior.
This is giving me comp.lang.lisp flashbacks.
On Clozure Common Lisp the breakeven point for the average case is 20 items (10 for the worst case).
Your condescending tone would at least not be completely unwarranted if you weren't utterly wrong.
Yes.
> and came up with a universal point
No. I got one data point.
Since there seems to be so much demand for it, I compared ALists and hash tables on Clozure Common Lisp. The breakeven point there was 20 items.
I believe the above to be an accurate summary.