Re:SpaceX Launches 19th Rocket in a Year, a Company Record
by max76 on Monday December 03, 2018 @06:33PM
(#18594297)
Asteroid mining would require brand new technology. We cannot crash an entire asteroid into Earth's surface, we would need to do zero g mineral processing, regardless of how the minerals are ultimately used. This is a task no one has ever done before. How do you estimate the cost of doing something like this? I'm not qualified, but I do know if a traditional mining organization decided to mine an asteroid the launch costs would be a small line item in their budget.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:SpaceX Launches 19th Rocket in a Year, a Company Record
by avmich on Monday December 03, 2018 @08:55PM
(#18595228)
The traditional NASA ideology is risk averse. It's way easier for them to spend billions doing all kinds of tests and modelling to ensure mission success on the first try. This looks suspiciously related to unwillingness to do multiple similar missions on the side of the customer - i.e. Congress in this case. Once in 1990-s there was an attempt to do things "faster, better, cheaper", which today could be named "move fast and break things", but with some inevitable failures the approach fell out of favor.
As for asteroid mining, Caterpillar was considering lunar base operation equipment on a previous iteration (G.W.Bush program). You probably right, they'd present a hefty bill, but I somehow doubt they'd offer something truly innovative. Maybe with new scrappy startups we can drastically slash those non-launch costs - then we'll come back again to the question of launch prices.
Re:SpaceX Launches 19th Rocket in a Year, a Company Record
by max76 on Monday December 03, 2018 @09:55PM
(#18595680)
> Maybe with new scrappy startups we can drastically slash those non-launch costs - then we'll come back again to the question of launch prices.
Over time asteroid/moon mining is inevitable. Technology will develop (costs fall), and we'll exhaust the mineral supply of Earth (prices increase). I'm sure, among many other types of organizations, scrappy startups will help us get there.