News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Brooke the Immortal: An American Child May Hold Secrets t... by grellas on Monday November 01, 2010 @07:31PM (#1858652)
The human race has a problem or two to solve before it can lay claim to "immortality."

For example:

1. The 20th century brought us the "war to end all wars," followed by a "lost generation" that essentially turned to boozing and high living as a way of escaping the loss of joy and the mass death of trench warfare; it brought us the mechanized warfare of WWII, by which devastation and death rained from the skies upon countless thousands of innocent people, the vision of a Third Reich and mass slaughter in ovens of an innocent religious group, from which thousands recoiled in horror but were powerless either to stop or to comprehend how such things were possible, and nuclear death that engulfed massive numbers of Japanese innocents, from which a mass stockpiling of such devastating weapons by the world's superpowers ensued, with follow-on proliferation now having reached into the hands of megalomaniacal dictators whose main claim to previously unthinkable levels of power will lie mainly in having developed such weapons and in being prepared potentially to use them, all followed by a "beat generation" that turned to drugs and other forms of escapism, and by a "hip generation" that did the same and by subsequent generations that are still groping in the dark, so to speak, to make sense of it all while somehow hoping that mankind will improve dramatically in its quest to achieve peace and tranquility notwithstanding all the sorry history to the contrary in ages past. As technology enables us to develop ever-greater forms of lethality, does anyone see "immortality" in his future even if one could live appreciably beyond the limit of 100 years that serves today as a pretty good measure of when the very few remaining representatives of a generation will in themselves be on the verge of dying. Yes, we all hope for solutions but let us see evidence of such solutions in action before laying claim to immortality.

2. The obvious problem that, when one reaches much beyond the age of 90, he begins to "fall apart." I know that is not a scientific phrase, but it accurately describes what happens when senility, dementia, and other mental problems attack the mind, when the body shrinks and most muscle mass is lost, when the skin deteriorates, and when cancer, congestive heart failure (or other heart disease), strokes, arterial, vascular, and blood problems, or any one of countless other illnesses attack and eventually overwhelm the body. And when there is no obvious illness, there is a winding down, a dying in one's sleep, a passing away owing to "natural causes." It would be one thing if some or most of these illnesses has been cured and scientists were able to say, "we are close and in a short while we will solve the remaining problems." It is quite another when science has not the slightest idea, based on today's knowledge, of how to solve even some of this onslaught of lethal conditions that affects us all at life's end.

3. The pure force of random accidents. This may not mean much if a lifespan is measured by a century. Multiply that by several centuries (assuming the other problems could be solved) and, in time, the odds will catch up with most people. Thus, solving the aging problem still leaves unsolved the cases of accidental, traumatic death, etc. that has never been a trivial problem at any point in history.

This piece, to my mind, projects fairly extreme forms of wish fulfillment in assuming that modern science is anywhere close to holding the "key" to solving any of this, much less in speculating that the answers lie in analyzing the genes of the little girl featured in this piece.

I understand the fascination of believing that potentially vast amounts of human betterment might result from the careful study of genetic conditions, and I have no doubt that much genuine progress can come from such studies. But science has to be tied to reality, above all things, and it does no service to its cause to deny the obvious (such as the items noted above), or to engage in what I believe are unsubstantiated speculations about "immortality," in hoping for the best from any given avenue of research.

Apart from speculating about immortality, this piece is interesting, and even fascinating, in highlighting the study of this young girl's unusual condition.

Re:Brooke the Immortal: An American Child May Hold Secrets t... by nostromo on Monday November 01, 2010 @10:36PM (#1859058)
I know it's only one part of your comment, but Steven Pinker argues very convincingly that human violence is at an all time low, even when including events like WWII.

Ted talk: http://www.ted.com/index.php/talks/steven_pinker_on_the_myth...

Chart of warfare deaths: http://www.martincwiner.com/wp-content/uploads/2008/02/maled... (Note: that last one includes 2 world wars!)

Edge article: http://www.edge.org/3rd_culture/pinker07/pinker07_index.html

Re:Brooke the Immortal: An American Child May Hold Secrets t... by narrator on Monday November 01, 2010 @10:58PM (#1859096)
World War II was really boring if you lived in South America at the time.
Re:Brooke the Immortal: An American Child May Hold Secrets t... by nostromo on Monday November 01, 2010 @11:01PM (#1859106)
Note that it says "US and Europe"
Re:Brooke the Immortal: An American Child May Hold Secrets t... by rbanffy on Monday November 01, 2010 @10:41PM (#1859067)
> The human race has a problem or two to solve before it can lay claim to "immortality.

This is not how technology advances. Advancements happen, problems are solved (and created) and we deal with them after the fact. We don't coordinate our efforts into an orderly march towards the future.

As much convenient as it would be otherwise.

Re:Brooke the Immortal: An American Child May Hold Secrets t... by ugh on Monday November 01, 2010 @08:43PM (#1858848)
While I agree with you in general I must say that I think your view of the 20th century is a bit too dystopian. Humanity has improved in the last one hundred years, and measurably so.
Re:Brooke the Immortal: An American Child May Hold Secrets t... by corprew on Monday November 01, 2010 @09:28PM (#1858935)
With what measurement, out of curiousity?
Re:Brooke the Immortal: An American Child May Hold Secrets t... by ugh on Monday November 01, 2010 @09:32PM (#1858939)
Standard stuff. Child mortality for example or GDP, literacy, poverty and so on. There are some countries which are lagging behind and some which have gone backwards but the planet as a whole has progressed.
Re:Brooke the Immortal: An American Child May Hold Secrets t... by Judson on Monday November 01, 2010 @10:29PM (#1859045)
I agree with all of that, except GDP. In an age of Fiat currency, GDP is nothing more than a proverbial phallus measuring contest. Paper is paper, is paper. Show me a real currency backed by something (Sorry, "faith" in the government doesn't count), and we can talk about progression on the GDP front.

Beyond that, surely child mortality, literacy, and poverty are enough to prove your point, GDP doesn't really even fit!

Re:Brooke the Immortal: An American Child May Hold Secrets t... by btilly on Monday November 01, 2010 @11:28PM (#1859157)
Show me a real currency backed by something (Sorry, "faith" in the government doesn't count), and we can talk about progression on the GDP front.

How about the fraction of disposable personal income spent on food?

http://www.ers.usda.gov/briefing/cpifoodandexpenditures/data...

From 1929 to the present that has dropped from 23.4% to 9.5%. This despite what other evidence suggests is a considerable increase in the quantity and overall quality of said food. For instance today we eat far more meat per capita than people did 80 years ago, and meat is rather expensive.

Re:Brooke the Immortal: An American Child May Hold Secrets t... by pyre on Tuesday November 02, 2010 @12:44AM (#1859309)

  > This despite what other evidence suggests is a considerable
  > increase in the quantity and overall quality of said food
1. What will our food production look like in the future after we have damaged the quality of our soil in much of the current areas that we are farming? Our normal solution is to 'just add fertilizer' to it, but that comes with its own cost, and it also has to come from somewhere.

Currently -- iirc -- most fertilizers come from livestock feces. My personal views on whether or not we should be 'farming living beings' notwithstanding... You have to feed those livestock something in order for them to produce feces. The current practice is to grow food for them (or to feed them the ground out remains of other livestock animals). So you need to grow more food in order grow more food? That doesn't seem sustainable.

This is not even getting to the issues we have with fertilizers running off into waterways and creating 'dead zones.'

2. The growth of 'comfort' or 'junk' foods I see as more of a regression than anything else. Their existence would be fine, if it weren't that some people don't know the meaning of moderation...

Re:Brooke the Immortal: An American Child May Hold Secrets t... by btilly on Tuesday November 02, 2010 @12:57AM (#1859329)
I'm not going to argue for the sustainability of our current technological society. I'm just saying that real wealth has increased quite markedly.
Re:Brooke the Immortal: An American Child May Hold Secrets t... by Judson on Tuesday November 02, 2010 @01:22AM (#1859369)
This is what I hate about HN. People who don't understand economics are inherently the people that are down-vote happy. Thats why I don't care one bit about karma.

You have chosen to compare what I was talking about, GDP (Nominal in this case) and a percentage of dollars (since you quote the USDA, I was talking about worldwide btw, just like the op) to food. It's an apples to oranges comparison, and for the most part, reinforces my comment above, that someone down-voted.

Yes, we spend less on food than we did in 1929. Do you have cows in your back yard btilly? Probably not. Why do I ask? Because comparing the farming industry in 1929 to the industry of 2010 is like comparing the age of slaughtering your own "home-raised" cow, to the age of mechanized cow raising, slaughtering, and delivery into the closest super market. Um, of course the price is lower. The real interesting part, though, is that the price could be even lower if the money supply wasn't artificially increased by trillions of dollars. Fun fact, if $1.00 would have purchased $1.00 worth of goods in 1929 (which it did), if you had instead, saved it until 2010, it would purchase ... wait for it ... $0.08 worth of goods. Does that not strike you as odd, that although productivity has boomed, e.g., we can make more things for less dollars, the value of the dollar has plummeted?

But to the main point, it shows by your argument that you failed to grasp the full extent of what I was saying. Money is just paper. How do I know that? When a country can lend itself (by selling its paper for another countries paper, in the case of the US, China purchases the vast majority of US treasuries, though, no one even knows if China is printing money, or being disciplined with their monetary policy) trillions of dollars and put that into circulation, of course the GDP will rise, but has progress been made? NO. GDP is nominal, not absolute, and it does not reflect productivity, or even actual PHYSICAL output! It reflects prices.

In a small country of 10 people, if all of those people have $1, and a barrel of oil is $1, the GDP is $10 or 10 barrels of oil. If the government prints up $10 more dollars and hands it out to those 10 people, now everyone has $20, but oil prices increase to $20 since MV = PQ. Ah, now the GDP is $20, but we can still only buy 10 barrels of oil. Now that is Your kind of progress.

My point, to wrap it up, was that things like global literacy and hunger are things we have been improving. Improving global GDP has no measurable impact by just inflating the number. The number is just a number unless it is put in real terms, which is not how the original post read when it listed "improving global GDP" as some kind of accomplishment.

Re:Brooke the Immortal: An American Child May Hold Secrets t... by btilly on Tuesday November 02, 2010 @03:17AM (#1859558)
It seems that you're on a rant against a straw man who has little resemblance to me. I'd prefer it if you address the points I've made, instead of the ones you think I've made.

Before you asked for a real currency, backed by something. With the implicit point that you don't believe the numbers.

Well my point is that any basket of goods implicitly defines a currency. Therefore food defines a currency, which is backed by the very real effort and resources it takes to produce that food. I've shown that GDP per capita in that "currency" has gone up. I presented figures for the USA because that is what I found first, but the same is true for the world as a whole. This is true at the same time that the number of people has gone up. Which means that food production must have gone up a lot.

You demanded a real measuring stick. I gave one. There is nothing special about that measuring stick. You can adjust for inflation using the CPI. You can adjust by many specific things we use daily, such as the cost of energy or metal. GDP has gone up.

Now you say that it is an apples and oranges comparison? Well of course it is! Productivity increases because we do things more efficiently. Using 1920s methods and technology we can't be any more productive today than we were 80 years ago. But we're using 2010 methods and technology, and there is a stark difference. The result is that today we generate more stuff, services, and things people want than at any point in history.

So yes, you are trivially right that inflation makes GDP numbers meaningless in isolation. But those numbers don't exist in isolation. We have lots of ways to adjust for inflation. After you have done so, it is clear that you can quibble about specific numbers but the broad point is good. Productivity has gone up.

Re:Brooke the Immortal: An American Child May Hold Secrets t... by Judson on Tuesday November 02, 2010 @10:20AM (#1860483)
Of course I am trivially right, I posted a trivial reply to something I was only nitpicking about (and I told the op I agreed, just not with GDP).

No one offered up inflation adjusted GDP, and my point, which was very simple, though long winded, was that you simply can't say "Increases in GDP make the world better".

Look at zimbabwe. Their GDP is Hundreds of Trillions of Zimbabwe dollars, because they print a 1 Trillion dollar note.

To be more fair, the OP would have been better off using your food example instead of saying "GDP rose". I wasn't arguing that we are worse off today than 1929, just that it isn't because of an increase in GDP. If the currency wasn't inflated, we could get better off with GDP staying constant, through productivity gains.

Re:Brooke the Immortal: An American Child May Hold Secrets t... by ugh on Tuesday November 02, 2010 @02:06AM (#1859444)
GDP might be not that meaningful but you can, for example, look at what share of humanity is still starving (thus getting a handle on poverty), how many people can afford a bike, a washing machine, a TV, a car, holidays on other continents and so on. That would give you a more realistic view on economic progress. GDP was my (probably ill-advised) way of saying that the economy has massively grown in the last hundred years. We can produce more things at a lower cost.