News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Brooke the Immortal: An American Child May Hold Secrets t... by guynamedloren on Monday November 01, 2010 @06:40PM (#1858533)
I've always wondered about the human body. Right now I am studying engineering, but eventually I would like to delve deep into anatomy and biology. An automobile can theoretically run forever as long as it is properly maintained, even if that means replacing major parts - engine, transmission, even frame (but at a certain point the repairs are no longer financially feasible). Why then, can't the human body last forever? As long as we are able to make repairs and replace parts when they fail, I don't understand why people have to die.

With all of the knowledge and advanced technology of today, something tells me we should be able to figure out how to stop aging - or at least slow it. We should be able to cure cancer. We should be able to cure AIDs. We should be able to regrow missing appendages or failed body parts. Am I the only one that thinks about these things? I would love to get involved in this field one day. I know there have been great advancements in these areas, but it seems like there is so much more that we could be doing.

Re:Brooke the Immortal: An American Child May Hold Secrets t... by orangecat on Monday November 01, 2010 @09:19PM (#1858923)
Am I the only one that thinks about these things?

No, but there's fewer of us than there should be. Which is sort of understandable; aging is terrible and until recently there wasn't much hope of doing anything about it, so not thinking about it may have been best. But today that strategy is counterproductive; we're spending trillions of dollars to slightly extend the lifespans of old people, but we won't spend even one percent of that investigating ways to prevent or repair the underlying damage done by aging.

FWIW I've started making semi-regular donations to the SENS Foundation. I believe their work has the potential to be tremendously valuable in terms of both economics and quality of life.

Re:Brooke the Immortal: An American Child May Hold Secrets t... by DennisP on Monday November 01, 2010 @08:31PM (#1858823)
You just described the SENS approach advocated by Aubrey de Grey. They're interested in getting help from engineers: http://www.sens.org/take-action/other-ways-to-help

De Grey published a book about their approach a couple years ago, and wikipedia has a basic overview: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strategies_for_Engineered_Negli...

Re:Brooke the Immortal: An American Child May Hold Secrets t... by possibilistic on Monday November 01, 2010 @09:39PM (#1858961)
Computational biochem student here. Unfortunately we do not have the technological prowess to replace parts of our body as they age. Researchers are working on growing whole organs from the extracellular scaffolds of cadavers, but this technique is in its infancy and I would take all news concerning it with a grain of salt.

Unfortunately, we are limited by which organs and tissues we can replace. Case in point: we cannot transplant the brain. Intracellular and extracellular buildup (eg. amyloid beta, lipofuscins, etc) will cause inflammation and cellular damage, and there is no way to remove them. Loss of telomeres and the accumulation of mutations leads to the breakdown of the genome, which is the host of the majority of a cell's state information. We ARE computer programs, and the moment memory gets corrupted things start to break down and behave improperly. The probability of any one of an unlimited number disease states in a cell correlates also with the level of misfolded, degraded, improperly tagged or trafficked gene products, which will always increase with time, even if the central program is well-behaved.

Remaining at homeostasis requires us to not reach chemical equilibrium, which requires we consume a ton of energy. Converting the necessary molecules during cellular metabolism puts our cells under heavy oxadative stress. Living requires a substantial number of evolved countermeasures, but eventually it will all catch up to us.

Why then are we so inept in our understanding of biology? The sheer astounding complexity of our biological machinery is not matched by any other problem that faces us. Biotechnology is amazing, but we are vastly limited by what we can do outside the context of in vitro techniques or simple, sacaled down in vivo assays. The real systm is always too complex to fully understand, and with so many unknowns we are essentially flying without radar. We can study proteins, promoters, etc. (slowly and with great difficulty) but we cannot "repair" them. We can't excise a damaged region of the genome and replace it at will. You would probably be shocked to see what techniques are actually even available--with my own limited experience it often feels like we are blindly throwing darts at targets that may not even exist. Our sequence information gives us clues, but we lack structural information (especially post-translational modifications) or knowledge of interaction details in the biochemical pathway.

If every physicist, computer scientist, mathematician or engineer stopped what they were doing and began work on this problem we might make some headway. Right now our hands are tied. This is absolutely the most important and complex problem in the world. We need the transcriptome, proteome, interactome, complete structure data, better algorithms, faster computers, higher resolution imaging (spatial, temporal, etc), better techniques, higher througput, I could go on and on. We certainly haven't entered the industrial age of biotech yet...

Do consider giving biology a try. We could use you and everyone willing. If you want to live twice as long, not get cancer or Alzheimer's, or cure any important infectious diseases, you should join us. Especially if you're a logical and abstract thinker.

Re:Brooke the Immortal: An American Child May Hold Secrets t... by Dn_Ab on Monday November 01, 2010 @10:54PM (#1859094)
I enjoy machine learning, pure and applied maths. Where do I start? Any books, any summaries of the state of the art for the computationally inclined? I ignorantly guess that graph theory, statistics and perhaps even group theory may provide useful perspectives? I know dynamical systems theory has been applied and hear you can code new simple organisms or something? Am I talking nonsense? heh This has always been an end goal of mine but I don't know where to begin. I figure start now and in 5 - 10 years I'll be ready to join you :)
Re:Brooke the Immortal: An American Child May Hold Secrets t... by possibilistic on Tuesday November 02, 2010 @12:31AM (#1859284)
Graph theory is applicable for exploring biochemical pathways, and all manner of statistics, ML, and metaheuristics are useful.

We can't "code" an organism, unfortunately. That won't be possible for some time. Venter has inserted a bacterial genome into a preexisting cell and called it "synthetic life", but this is hyperbole. He essentially just swapped out the operating system if you will. Both the genome and the cell were preexisting. This would be impossible to do for a eukaryotic cell with any of today's technology since we have extremely complicated molecular (genomic) machinery. Not to mention how much of our state information is epigenetic--precise methylation, etc.

We certainly cannot create novel proteins outside of fusions between subunits. Protein folding is just way too difficult to solve. If we ever figure it out, society will change overnight.

If you would like to study this, get some texts on cell physiology, molecular biology (genetics++), and maybe do some reading on higher level function. Like me you will see that your existing skill set is not immediately transferrable until you learn enough biology: you cannot effectively program in a language until you really know it innately. Biology is the same way, just much, much more sysemitized, complex and abstract. It has a very high barrier to entry (akin to learning Vim, but takes longer.)

Re:Brooke the Immortal: An American Child May Hold Secrets t... by JabavuAdams on Monday November 01, 2010 @10:48PM (#1859084)
Can I ask you three questions?

1) What are the names of the courses you're taking this year? 2) What books are you reading for your studies? 3) Who would you most want to work with, in your field?

Re:Brooke the Immortal: An American Child May Hold Secrets t... by possibilistic on Tuesday November 02, 2010 @12:15AM (#1859257)
I'm done with my undergrad CS and Bio education (with a few exceptions), and now I'm working on the finishing up on chem--then it's time for grad school. My biggest worry is that I do not know enough physics... I'm hoping P.chem rectifies that.

For the next academic year I'm taking the following: Biotechnology, Physical chemistry, Analytical chemistry, Instrumental analysis, Biochemistry, Drug design, Cancer bio, and doing some limited original research.

My favorite books in the past were "Cell and Molecular Biology" by Karp, "Molecular Biology" by Weaver, and "Janeway's Immunobiology", all of which enabled me to read the primary literature and contributed greatly to how I now see the world. There are also a bunch of poor or suboptimal ones that are not really worth worth pursuing. Once you read a few good texts, jumping right into a journal of interest is highly integrative!

Perhaps this is unwise of me, but I haven't yet made note of any of the people that are doing the reseach I'm most interested in. Even if I did, I probably won't be able to do work with them at this early stage.

In any case, my hope is that I can spend most of my time coding and searching through the chemical state space and biochemical pathways with computers. I strongly feel high-throughput techniques are indespensible and need to be utilized to make the best use of limited, prescious time. I would still enjoy spending some days in the lab running assays as they can also be quite fun.

Re:Brooke the Immortal: An American Child May Hold Secrets t... by JabavuAdams on Tuesday November 02, 2010 @12:18PM (#1861044)
Thanks, and good luck!
Re:Brooke the Immortal: An American Child May Hold Secrets t... by DennisP on Tuesday November 02, 2010 @10:15AM (#1860461)
"Intracellular and extracellular buildup" are two of the problems the SENS people are trying to fix. It sounds like you'd be interested in Aubrey de Grey's book...he goes into a lot of detail on their ideas.

On another note, Kary Mullis has a clever idea that he thinks could make cures for all infections diseases: http://www.edge.org/3rd_culture/mullis10/mullis10_index.html

Re:Brooke the Immortal: An American Child May Hold Secrets t... by adrianwaj on Tuesday November 02, 2010 @12:12PM (#1861011)
Dental health is really interesting to me right now. There are cultures that have little decay but don't clean there teeth. It's all in the diet. I am also interested in Weston Price's research into Root Canals causing all manner of diseases - the idea being that bacteria and toxins can remain in the tubules of dead teeth and with this as a base, branch into other parts of the body. Dental health is linked to longevity.
Re:Brooke the Immortal: An American Child May Hold Secrets t... by chc on Monday November 01, 2010 @07:14PM (#1858616)
We ought to be able to design a perfect programming language and correspondingly flawless framework, but somehow reality always gets in the way.