Agree. This guy seem to have a bad case of confirmation bias (1). The question was "What role did the Internet campaign play _in convincing you_ to hold this rally? Don't pander" (2), not if it helped to make it possible.
(1) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Confirmation_bias#Biased_interp... (2) http://edition.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/1010/30/cnr.07.html
When asked the question, Colbert jumped in and preempted the answer to thank Reddit for raising half a million dollars for Donors Choose. Both Colbert and Stewart said the Internet support was nice, validated their idea, and they were thankful for it. Colbert in particularly clearly knew exactly who Reddit was.
On the other hand, both of them independently said that the rally was in planning months before anyone on Reddit brought it to their attention. Reddit wasn't instrumental the rally. Get over it. Glen Beck and Louis Farrakhan were also able to get hundreds of thousands of people to the national mall; Farrakhan doesn't even have a top-rated TV show to do it with.