Re:No wonder CompSci grads are unemployed
by philwelch on Monday November 01, 2010 @02:03PM
(#1857455)
I have a BA too, so your comment is interesting to me even though I have a somewhat dissenting perspective.
To begin with, "the arts" (defined as anything you can get a BA in) is a wide, wide field. At my university, a BA is often a less rigorous degree option in fields that also offer BS degrees. You can't talk about BA's generally--they range from various instances of "Identity Politics: The Major" to pretty tricky stuff, like philosophy, which at its highest levels is comparable to advanced mathematics.
Philosophy has a lot of intellectual content that's difficult for people to grasp, because you're basically taking raw logic and using it to blow up fundamental parts of people's belief systems. Getting people to take the skeptical argument seriously is an ordeal in itself, much less coming up with intelligent responses to it. Even after you get past tricks like that, it's a rough slog reading philosophy. Analytic philosophy, which is exceptionally rigorous, is about as difficult to read as mathematics; other philosophy is even more difficult if it has any meaning at all.
Philosophy actually exercises most of the same muscles as math and CS, in my experience; learning to think of counterexamples as you write general statements is a skill you pick up in all three contexts. Counterexamples in philosophy fill largely the same role as test cases in software development--any attempt to define "knowledge" in the past half century has had to contend with Gettier's famous counterexample (http://www.ditext.com/gettier/gettier.html) which sunk Plato's millennia-old definition.
In terms of contemplating the human condition? If I had to manage actual people, I'd look for a psychology or anthropology grad, and both of those can be had as BS degrees. One of the coolest (and most useful!) things philosophy ever gave us was empiricism, and so far, psychologists and anthropologists are the ones applying empiricism to humans in the contexts most useful for something like running a company. But actually, I don't know if formal education helps at all with management. If I was going to hire a political leader with vast amounts of power, I sure as hell want someone who understands history. (And I'd hire a poli sci major to manage his campaign, naturally.)
To begin with, "the arts" (defined as anything you can get a BA in) is a wide, wide field. At my university, a BA is often a less rigorous degree option in fields that also offer BS degrees. You can't talk about BA's generally--they range from various instances of "Identity Politics: The Major" to pretty tricky stuff, like philosophy, which at its highest levels is comparable to advanced mathematics.
Philosophy has a lot of intellectual content that's difficult for people to grasp, because you're basically taking raw logic and using it to blow up fundamental parts of people's belief systems. Getting people to take the skeptical argument seriously is an ordeal in itself, much less coming up with intelligent responses to it. Even after you get past tricks like that, it's a rough slog reading philosophy. Analytic philosophy, which is exceptionally rigorous, is about as difficult to read as mathematics; other philosophy is even more difficult if it has any meaning at all.
Philosophy actually exercises most of the same muscles as math and CS, in my experience; learning to think of counterexamples as you write general statements is a skill you pick up in all three contexts. Counterexamples in philosophy fill largely the same role as test cases in software development--any attempt to define "knowledge" in the past half century has had to contend with Gettier's famous counterexample (http://www.ditext.com/gettier/gettier.html) which sunk Plato's millennia-old definition.
In terms of contemplating the human condition? If I had to manage actual people, I'd look for a psychology or anthropology grad, and both of those can be had as BS degrees. One of the coolest (and most useful!) things philosophy ever gave us was empiricism, and so far, psychologists and anthropologists are the ones applying empiricism to humans in the contexts most useful for something like running a company. But actually, I don't know if formal education helps at all with management. If I was going to hire a political leader with vast amounts of power, I sure as hell want someone who understands history. (And I'd hire a poli sci major to manage his campaign, naturally.)