News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Retail Arbitrage at Walmart [video] by ams6110 on Friday November 30, 2018 @03:39PM (#18572427)
Why would manufacturers hate it?
Re:Retail Arbitrage at Walmart [video] by unethical_ban on Friday November 30, 2018 @04:20PM (#18572729)
Alternative to the other explanation: The only reason it would be a grey market activity is because the vehicle is more expensive in the native market.

So Widgets Ltd. is selling widgets for $100 in China, but $30 in the US. Lots of money to be made in the gap.

Re:Retail Arbitrage at Walmart [video] by gh02t on Friday November 30, 2018 @04:49PM (#18573003)
Indeed, I suspect it has to do with manufacturer's wanting control over prices and supply. E.g. a manufacturer thinks they can charge a higher base price in China because they are a luxury foreign brand.
Re:Retail Arbitrage at Walmart [video] by newnewpdro on Friday November 30, 2018 @03:43PM (#18572460)
Presumably because the manufacturers pay tariffs and other expenses in the course of legally bringing vehicles to foreign countries. Now they're competing with folks evading those overheads, on selling their own product, which they've already paid to to bring stock of legally.
Re:Retail Arbitrage at Walmart [video] by Consultant32452 on Friday November 30, 2018 @04:18PM (#18572718)
I'm still confused. The people doing this are presumably paying retail for those vehicles, so the manufacturer and dealership got their profits out of it. What do they care if someone skirts taxes as long as they made their profit on the retail sale?
Re:Retail Arbitrage at Walmart [video] by newnewpdro on Friday November 30, 2018 @05:19PM (#18573256)
This isn't an area I'm experienced with, but there seems to be some rather obvious problems and I suspect there are far more than I'm considering in this brief thought exercise.

The price of the illegally imported equivalents will be substantially lower than those legally imported by the manufacturer.

This will have the effect of driving down the FMV of the vehicle in the region.

But if the manufacturer can't afford to match that FMV because of legal trade and transport overheads, the effect will be reduced sales of the vehicle in the region overall, because the illegal channels obviously can't operate on a large enough scale to 100% replace the legal channel from the manufacturer's perspective.

The illegal channel doesn't have to (and won't) operate at legal-replacement scales to impact the region's perception of the vehicle's FMV.

Also consider what effect it may have on potential buyers interested in buying legally, but exposed to news of the imported brand being so overpriced and so desirable that there's a substantial illicit market emerging to fulfill that demand. The honest consumer might be completely turned off by this, thinking their new car may be a theft target because it's this desirable import brand people are committing risky trade crimes just to sell as new in the country.

The situation seems likely to harm the overall sales volume for the region.

Re:Retail Arbitrage at Walmart [video] by wtvanhest on Friday November 30, 2018 @04:56PM (#18573066)
Most businesses price discriminate by geography. A car manufacturer may charge $25,000 USD for a car in the US, but $35,000 USD for a very similar car in Asia. Brands carry different values depending on market. The car company does not want to lose out on that $10,000/car surplus.