And you know what? H1-B labor isn't cheap. My girlfriend is paid $10K more because she speaks Japanese and can communicate with Japanese clients. You actually have to prove to USCIS that you are paying at least market rate, if not more than market rate because of a shortage of labor. I hire people on a regular basis, and I am very familiar with the H1-B process, having seen two of my team members being forced back home because they failed to proceed with the process from the quota lottery.
Again, it's not a binary problem. There are obviously abuser of the H1-B program, and there are businesses, even industries, that benefit from immigrants. You know what really pushed US innovation forward in the last 50 years? I believe immigrants pushed US innovation more than any thing else. Charles K. Kao, a naturalized American, made the US his home and won a Nobel last year for his work in optics during the 70s. Sun Microsystems founder is German, and so is Peter Thiel. William Boyle of Bell Labs. Londoner, now American, Jack Szostak of Harvard Medical School. Taiwan immigrant David Ho for his work in AIDS. Hell, Einstein was a US immigrant.
I making more at my current job (~$130k/year) than I ever have and likely will for a while. However, in many other ways it's a very poor fit and long-term I believe it's a professional dead-end. But since I am currently applying for a green card through this job, I am stuck in it until I get the green card which could take anywhere from 2 - 5 years. If I get another job in the US (which I would have no problem doing w/ my skill-set) or lost this job I would have to restart the green card application process, losing at least 1.5 years. On top of that my wife cannot legally work in the US until I have my green card. She is a high-school teacher with 10 years of experience in international schools in Asia and, ironically, has a master's degree in education from an American university (although the course-work was done in Asia).
So I can definitely sympathize w/ Americans who feel that H1B workers like myself are undercutting the American IT job market--because we are! H1B jobs hold out the eventual promise of a green card, but in the meantime if you're in my situation you have to put up w/ a lousy job and pass on better paying and more interesting jobs. For some that promise of a green card is worth it, but for me it is not, so we're pulling up stakes so that I can practice my craft as a free man.
How do you expect this to not be offensive? Drop the fake courtesy.
While we are laying out anecdotal evidence in support of our causes let me just say that when I got a job straight out of college I had better offers than most of my American classmates. I for one was not a cheap replacement for domestic labor.
Even if that were the case you can't talk about the broken H1B system without talking about the broken Green Card process. Give people an easy path to a GC and they have no reason to work below market wages. But if you simply do not want to complete with people who happen to not be born in your country then that's a different issue.
There are plenty of reasons to leave the country you are born in, and not all of them implies that you had it worse before. Wanting to get away from comfort and familiarity is in itself a reason to emigrate.
(I'm hoping the above job link does not count as spam in this context, but I will edit and remove it if so)
http://www.economist.com/blogs/freeexchange/2010/09/economic...
My girlfriend also works here and it's going to take her years to get back the tens of thousands of hard-earned euros she invested in her Master's. I have many friends in that plane.
> ... a bunch of H1B toting immigrants ...
on the other hand "us native minions" (as you termed it) have an interest in artificially reducing the availability of skill in the labor market. some of your tone makes me think there's also an element of this in your stance?
i can't agree with the idea of restricting labor on the basis of the coincidence of where someone was born. there might be a sociological argument to be made when considering unskilled labor from less developed countries - but how can anyone justify restricting skilled labor, and movement between countries with socioeconomic parity (us/canada/eu/japan/etc.)?
Really, though, my overall complaint was that this fluff piece tried to say "Immigrants create more jobs" when statistically speaking, they often take more jobs than they save, and only on very rare occasions actually create brand new shiny jobs that help the unemployment situation.
My anger doesn't even remotely apply to the cream of the crop, the genuine masterminds who come here to work their magic. Whether they're founders or very senior level hackers. Most of them aren't being underpaid here, and they're not contributing to the problem. They're not par for the course, either.
so what would your argument be against just an average programmer, say from japan, being hired to work at a company in the bay area?
Given the possibility that you have to leave the US if you lose an H1B job (unless you can find a new one immediately), that makes you less likely to buy a house or a decent car that you will have trouble unloading if you have to leave on short notice. And I have deliberately shifted savings into cash vs. a 401k plan because I can take the cash with me when I leave.