News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sedans Aren’t Dead, American Sedans Are by rock_hard on Friday November 30, 2018 @12:44PM (#18570801)
Well, this assumes that it’s all about TCO or status.

But have you ever driven a Mercedes, BMW, Porsche or Audi? The driving expierence is superior to everything else! Tesla gets close...but I can’t think of any other brand that does.

Re:Sedans Aren’t Dead, American Sedans Are by jszymborski on Friday November 30, 2018 @12:48PM (#18570839)
I think it's fair to say this falls under grandparent's "enthusiast" category. Nothing wrong with being an enthusiast, but I think the characterization as "irrational" is probably correct.
Re:Sedans Aren’t Dead, American Sedans Are by mikeash on Friday November 30, 2018 @01:08PM (#18571053)
Few human decisions are rational if you start taking that approach. You can always live in a smaller dwelling, wear worse clothes, eat cheaper food, avoid all paid entertainment, etc.

It would be better to state that the car market is not primarily based around the simple act of transportation. Which should be pretty obvious anyway.

Re:Sedans Aren’t Dead, American Sedans Are by exergy on Friday November 30, 2018 @02:33PM (#18571905)
> You can always live in a smaller dwelling, wear worse clothes, eat cheaper food, avoid all paid entertainment, etc.

Indeed. And the more of these you can check, the happier and more satisfying your life is likely to get. Why maintain an unused mansion when a small, cozy place will do? Why follow the latest fashion trends when your four year old OCBD is in fighting form? Why eat lobsters all the time when beans are so nutrient-dense and cheap?! Why sit on your ass wasting away at the behest of a mediocre film when you could read a book instead?

The other major difference, of course, is that there are few irrational decisions quite as expensive as buying an idiot pickup truck to show off. Maybe a boat or an aircraft, but not much more.

Re:Sedans Aren’t Dead, American Sedans Are by mikeash on Friday November 30, 2018 @02:45PM (#18572007)
Why have a small, cozy place when you could live in a van down by the river? Why buy clothes when you can drape yourselves in discarded blankets? Why eat beans when you can haunt the dumpsters behind the local restaurants?
Re:Sedans Aren’t Dead, American Sedans Are by exergy on Friday November 30, 2018 @02:57PM (#18572095)
Reductio ad absurdum
Re:Sedans Aren’t Dead, American Sedans Are by mikeash on Friday November 30, 2018 @03:33PM (#18572370)
Yes, exactly. Calling it "irrational" to spend resources on pleasure leads to absurd conclusions. Reductio ad absurdum is not a fallacy.
Re:Sedans Aren’t Dead, American Sedans Are by exergy on Saturday December 01, 2018 @12:50AM (#18575447)
Of course it's a fallacy. One has to draw a line at some point. To me that line would be a way, way cheaper expense than a big, polluting truck. But it seems that to you, if I can't own a truck, I must go all the way to living in shanties/favelas and dumpster diving.
Re:Sedans Aren’t Dead, American Sedans Are by mikeash on Saturday December 01, 2018 @08:02AM (#18576595)
How do you decide where to draw the line? What’s the rational way to put some pleasures under the “rational” category and others under the “irrational” category?
Re:Sedans Aren’t Dead, American Sedans Are by Noumenon72 on Saturday December 01, 2018 @07:50PM (#18580065)
You calibrate on what people were satisfied with thirty or a hundred years ago, eliminating modern status-seeking. You ask yourself "Would I be horrified to live like that, or do I just think I'm too good for it?" Like there's no way I am going to live as a boarder with another family, but I can definitely make my own lunch.
Re:Sedans Aren’t Dead, American Sedans Are by mikeash on Saturday December 01, 2018 @09:27PM (#18580402)
Why thirty or a hundred? Why not two, or ten thousand?
Re:Sedans Aren’t Dead, American Sedans Are by matthewmcg on Friday November 30, 2018 @12:50PM (#18570857)
The top level post was edited to add the line about enthusiasts after this was posted.
Re:Sedans Aren’t Dead, American Sedans Are by d1zzy on Friday November 30, 2018 @09:46PM (#18574753)
Life is too short to make saving money the first priority on every decision. Drive whatever you can afford and makes happiest (and makes sense for the use case you have in mind for it, offroad, snow, racing, commute time, etc).
Re:Sedans Aren’t Dead, American Sedans Are by vinay427 on Friday November 30, 2018 @12:54PM (#18570897)
BMW's recent models are mostly a joke in dynamics. See almost any review of many of their new models for further explanation. This unfortunately isn't 2010 anymore.

Mercedes hasn't been kenown for driving dynamics, but perhaps their solidity is great. Porsche is absolutely renowned for the driving experience they provide.

There are plenty that can match these in every class. If you only consider brands based on an overall perception, then sure, maybe not.

The Cadillac ATS and Alfa Romeo Giulia are almost universally regarded as dynamically superior to their 3-series equivalents, for a common example.

Re:Sedans Aren’t Dead, American Sedans Are by 2trill2spill on Friday November 30, 2018 @01:49PM (#18571482)
> The Cadillac ATS and Alfa Romeo Giulia are almost universally regarded as dynamically superior to their 3-series equivalents, for a common example.

Exactly, my 2017 Focus RS is so much fun to drive and has a lot more power than any German car of equivalent price. I mean where else can you find AWD, 350 HP and 350 ft/lb torque with a 6 speed manual for under $40,000?

Re:Sedans Aren’t Dead, American Sedans Are by fein on Friday November 30, 2018 @03:12PM (#18572195)
A used R32 or Golf R and a stage 2 ecu tune (downpipe) will easily do it, and be a better car overall.

I like the RS a lot, but not $40,000 a lot.

Re:Sedans Aren’t Dead, American Sedans Are by 2trill2spill on Friday November 30, 2018 @03:53PM (#18572529)
Your comparing the price of a used car vs a new car? Of course the used car will be cheaper. A Golf R brand new is more expensive then a new Focus RS. Also I'm a Minnesotan I need a real AWD system not the Haldex system in the Golf R, which is basically FWD unless it detects low traction then it will engage the back wheels. Also the Golf R has only 288HP and 280FT/LB torque compared to my cars 350HP and 350FT/LB torque so I'm not sure why you think the Golf R is the "Better" car.
Re:Sedans Aren’t Dead, American Sedans Are by cbm-vic-20 on Friday November 30, 2018 @02:24PM (#18571833)
> where else can you find AWD, 350 HP and 350 ft/lb torque with a 6 speed manual for under $40,000?

Not Ford, anymore.

Re:Sedans Aren’t Dead, American Sedans Are by 2trill2spill on Friday November 30, 2018 @02:29PM (#18571872)
Yea sure, but we all knew the Focus RS was a limited production release and they would only be making it for a couple years.
Re:Sedans Aren’t Dead, American Sedans Are by mav3rick on Friday November 30, 2018 @01:05PM (#18571015)
The Audis were better than any other Japanese car I test drove.
Re:Sedans Aren’t Dead, American Sedans Are by vinay427 on Friday November 30, 2018 @04:41PM (#18572925)
That's quite reasonable, and I may agree depending on what exact cars you test drove, but that's a rather different statement than the one made in the comment I replied to.
Re:Sedans Aren’t Dead, American Sedans Are by jcims on Friday November 30, 2018 @09:02PM (#18574557)
S series yes (have an S5 and an SQ5). A series pretty much drive like a Toyota minus the reliability.
Re:Sedans Aren’t Dead, American Sedans Are by sk5t on Saturday December 01, 2018 @12:14AM (#18575318)
Had a B8.5 S4, now a B9 A5 with sports suspension. The power/transmission leave a little something to be desired, but the A5 is otherwise a very nice ride, and not too wallowy for an Audi. I have also a much more powerful sports car for the weekend, but the A5 has its charms too.
Re:Sedans Aren’t Dead, American Sedans Are by mav3rick on Saturday December 01, 2018 @10:06AM (#18577046)
I love the A4 drive as well.
Re:Sedans Aren’t Dead, American Sedans Are by seanmcdirmid on Friday November 30, 2018 @06:32PM (#18573761)
I would believe that for Acura or infinity, but Lexus?
Re:Sedans Aren’t Dead, American Sedans Are by amartya916 on Friday November 30, 2018 @12:59PM (#18570955)
Completely agreed. Similarly, most cars in Jaguar's current portfolio have good Dynamics.
Re:Sedans Aren’t Dead, American Sedans Are by Johnny555 on Friday November 30, 2018 @03:45PM (#18572475)
Is that true in typical urban driving conditions of stop and go, or at least slow traffic? I think the only thing that would help make my driving experience better in this traffic would be radar cruise control that can handle stop/go traffic.

I've found that the best driving experience in my commute conditions is a $500,000 bus because I can get some work done or relax so the length of the commute doesn't mattter so much.

Re:Sedans Aren’t Dead, American Sedans Are by crispyambulance on Friday November 30, 2018 @01:01PM (#18570968)

    > The driving experience is superior
Driving experience only goes so far in bumper-to-bumper traffic. Those aren't cars that people "need". Most lux car owners will also have a "beater" car that they use for real life.

Status is an important motivator and should not be dismissed.

Re:Sedans Aren’t Dead, American Sedans Are by mikeash on Friday November 30, 2018 @01:09PM (#18571065)
That’s no longer true with the driver assistance systems available now. Some cars provide a vastly superior driving experience in heavy traffic now.
Re:Sedans Aren’t Dead, American Sedans Are by compiler-guy on Friday November 30, 2018 @04:37PM (#18572890)
But people don't drive only in bumper-to-bumper traffic. That is the most common use, but nearly everyone has some open road time now and again.
Re:Sedans Aren’t Dead, American Sedans Are by MoBattah on Friday November 30, 2018 @01:18PM (#18571157)
Driven Benz, BMW, Porsche, Audi, Tesla, Rolls Royce, Ferrari, Lamborghini, etc.

No way in hell is a C-Class Benz worth it's price. Tesla drives way better and is much more fun.

I think it's about TCO, status, reliability and maybe fun-factor.

Nobody buys an Audi or Benz for 'fun-factor'. Especially not when they get AMG or i versions.

Re:Sedans Aren’t Dead, American Sedans Are by mprev on Friday November 30, 2018 @02:09PM (#18571698)
Nobody buys an AMG for fun?
Re:Sedans Aren’t Dead, American Sedans Are by hi5eyes on Friday November 30, 2018 @03:11PM (#18572191)
they mean the majority of people get them for the badging, AMG are definitely the most fun sonically but most people arent bothering with straight piping or any fun performance mods. its mainly a flex
Re:Sedans Aren’t Dead, American Sedans Are by esotericn on Friday November 30, 2018 @12:46PM (#18570819)
Right, that's the enthusiast market.
Re:Sedans Aren’t Dead, American Sedans Are by lostmsu on Friday November 30, 2018 @01:18PM (#18571158)
I had driven BMW 3s and Minis via ReachNow. Did not feel anything special vs my Honda, or any rental I had.
Re:Sedans Aren’t Dead, American Sedans Are by hi5eyes on Friday November 30, 2018 @03:17PM (#18572239)
none of those cars are supposed to feel anything special, the 3 series is the entry level scrap bmw puts out to get people onto the brand and the newer bmws are last among the germans

mini, owned by bmw, is.. mini.. theyre the car parents get their daughters

Re:Sedans Aren’t Dead, American Sedans Are by dreamcompiler on Friday November 30, 2018 @01:20PM (#18571175)
I love my Audi S4, but I find the Tesla Model S to be even more fun than my car. Unfortunately it's too expensive.
Re:Sedans Aren’t Dead, American Sedans Are by nickik on Friday November 30, 2018 @12:46PM (#18570825)
I bet that you could not pick a BMW or Audi from equally priced car from other companies.
Re:Sedans Aren’t Dead, American Sedans Are by Domenic_S on Friday November 30, 2018 @12:57PM (#18570924)
I didn't downvote you, but I bet I could [pick them out]. They just value different things compared to american counterparts, especially in older models.

I (regrettably used to) own a 2002 BMW M3 -- relatively cheap to buy, and compared to anything else in its year or price category was unequivocally better as a "driver's car". But, many people don't really care about a driver's car -- they index higher on other things like electronics, safety, styling, etc. That's fine, it's only preference, but for raw performance nothing similar could compare.

My experience is that a lot of people equate "expensive car" or "german car" with "nice car", and for them "nice car" means something specific other than raw performance numbers, like comfort, safety, features, or Consumer Reports ranking. For enthusiasts, it means something totally different, and those qualities are indexed on by BMW/Merc/Audi (and some rare American and Japanese exceptions to be fair).