My brother is a medical student, and I find myself asking him for opinion on medical issues from time to time. I do that when the problem isn't (or doesn't seem) serious, and I don't treat his answers as if they came from MD. The reason is simple: going to a doctor is an expensive and time-consuming endeavour, whereas I can ask my brother things casually whenever I come visit.
If you ain't gonna go to the doctor over something anyway, asking a medical student you know still beats trying to "research" things on the Internet.
Real questions I've been asked:
- Can I dissolve these tablets? Turns out the answer was in the Product Information - yes, you can.
- What happens if I mix my SSRIs with illicit substances? I don't know, could be bad, please don't, if you do consider standard harm reduction strategies.
I do comment on the odd medical post on HN. Usually trying to dispell myths or offer some evidence that helps the discussion - a Cochrane review, or a Lancet article, etc. Occasionally I try to defend the profession, or explain some of the difficulty that doctors are in that leads people to be frustrated with them. I also blog a little, as an outlet for all the crazyness and feelings that come with medical training. That said, you won't be seeing and product endorsements from me.
I don't see any harm in offering reasonable advice or adding a little evidence to discussions. I'm always careful to point out my student status, and not to offer medical advice directly.