News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Latest Crop of Instagram Influencers: Medical Students by Waterluvian on Friday November 30, 2018 @07:37AM (#18568634)
I generally agree. But experts could also stand to improve their ability to give meaningful actionable advice, separated from all the various information that may be useful as part of the broader discussion/treatment.

I asked a handyman community the other day if my furnace running 22 hours a day during the winter is normal and how furnaces work.

I got about a dozen "it depends..." answers that enumerated all the factors involving a house heating and cooling until someone basically said, "no it doesn't really depend. That's very much not normal regardless of any factors. You'd have to be in a really unusual situation for this to be normal and not warrant further investigation."

Re:The Latest Crop of Instagram Influencers: Medical Students by tcbawo on Friday November 30, 2018 @08:04AM (#18568751)
If the fear of being publicly proven wrong or held liable causes people to hedge/water down their advice, maybe this creates a space that allows frauds, charlatans, and confident fools to thrive.
Re:The Latest Crop of Instagram Influencers: Medical Students by wonthegame on Friday November 30, 2018 @10:08AM (#18569577)
I think any professional that takes on liabilities should have this view. Confidence fools many people.
Re:The Latest Crop of Instagram Influencers: Medical Students by pixl97 on Friday November 30, 2018 @08:47AM (#18569043)
> That's very much not normal regardless of any factors.

See, this is the problem with you not being an expert in the field.

For example, if your house had terrible insulation and it was -10 out. Yea, that thing is going to run all day. If you had a new house, but left all your windows open, yea it will run all day too. So, yea, "it depends' is a perfectly cromulent answer without you giving lots of information.

People that don't have much experience are the ones that will say "yep, it's broke" right off the bat. When I was younger and you asked "Can you make my software stack faster", I'd have answered yes. These days "It depends", probably followed by "How much money do you want to spend".

TL:DR; The complexity of reality doesn't give a damn how simple you want your problem to be.

Re:The Latest Crop of Instagram Influencers: Medical Students by cglace on Friday November 30, 2018 @09:23AM (#18569276)
But both of those situations are not normal. He did not ask if it was possible for an AC to run for 22 hours a day. He asked it was normal. If someone asked if it was normal for a page to take 10 mins to load I would say no. However, I would then list circumstances where that would make sense.
Re:The Latest Crop of Instagram Influencers: Medical Students by Waterluvian on Friday November 30, 2018 @09:44AM (#18569414)
Right. I'm not discarding the value of the details. But right now I just want to know, "does it seem like I might have a problem?"

As a non expert I wouldn't have been surprised if someone said, "yeah it's pretty common for furnaces to run non stop in cold winters. That's their design."

Re:The Latest Crop of Instagram Influencers: Medical Students by thaeli on Friday November 30, 2018 @01:17PM (#18571140)
And if you were asking about air conditioning in the summer, that would be the answer. Moderately "oversizing" a furnace vs. the heat loss calcs doesn't cause major problems; for air conditioning it does, with an oversized unit you don't get adequate humidity control. But for furnaces, to get noticeable negative effects you have to MASSIVELY oversize. The upshot of this (and other factors such as needing to upsize the furnace to get enough air handler capacity for the cooling load in summer) is that no, if your furnace is firing almost constantly all winter, something is probably wrong. That "wrong" is likely to be "the furnace itself is working fine, but you don't have enough insulation and your windows are super drafty", but for purposes of the basic "is this normal".. no. It's not, given common North American residential HVAC practice. Certainly worth further investigation.

Importantly in this case, the outside temperature at which your heat or AC runs constantly is the maximum where your house will maintain temperature. So, because of the different tradeoffs of oversizing heat vs AC, normal practice is to put in enough AC for a typical summer (and just let the house get a little warmer during a heat wave) so that dehumidification remains optimal, and to put in enough heating for a worst-case cold snap because, well, it doesn't hurt much and people REALLY complain when their house gets cold in the winter.

Re:The Latest Crop of Instagram Influencers: Medical Students by dsfyu404ed on Friday November 30, 2018 @11:57AM (#18570426)
>As a non expert I wouldn't have been surprised if someone said, "yeah it's pretty common for furnaces to run non stop in cold winters. That's their design."

This was not uncommon in rich (big houses) older (built up before WW2) towns in MA because the houses are big and old and state law regarding who can perform plumbing/electrical/hvac work greatly drive up costs and are a massive incentive to always minimum amount of work possible so tons of people would have poorly insulated houses with smaller than ideal heating systems. For the coldest days in the winter many people's furnaces would run all day to keep the house warm (whereas poor people just turn down the heat).

This has changed recently because the state is pumping a ton of money into incentives for people to make their homes energy efficient now basically every old house has had insulation blown in everywhere because with state subsidies the cost to do so is now justifiable in the overwhelming majority of use cases.

Re:The Latest Crop of Instagram Influencers: Medical Students by dsfyu404ed on Friday November 30, 2018 @11:51AM (#18570389)
The edge cases in which it is "normal" are frequent enough that "it depends" becomes a better answer than "no"