News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Dystopian Fiction Shapes Political Attitudes by gerdesj on Thursday November 29, 2018 @09:08PM (#18566023)
"In political science" - they assert this is science.

This is how they decide what to test:

"In formulating hypotheses, we draw from several theoretical traditions. The majority of our hypotheses flow from the nature of the content shared across dystopian narratives. We take each theoretical tradition in turn."

This appears to describe the difference between fact and fantasy:

"Scholars in the narrative persuasion tradition distinguish narrative from rhetorical persuasion, where the latter is characterized by advocacy of a position through arguments, reasoning, and evidence (e.g., newspaper editorials and political speeches). By contrast, narrative persuasion involves attitude change driven by cognitive and emotional engagement with a story."

This is experiment three:

"Finally, we test two key folk hypotheses, loosely connected to cultivation theory."

Science is hard:

"Yet an experimental manipulation involving an entire story narrative can be difficult to unpack and interpret."

Overall, I found this paper hard to read (to be fair, I'm not used to seeing this style of thing but I have put some effort in - I read it!) and rather vapid.

Re:How Dystopian Fiction Shapes Political Attitudes by aesto on Thursday November 29, 2018 @11:34PM (#18566700)
Perspectives on Politics isn't exactly a top-drawer journal. It's the sort of outlet where articles (often more on the philosophical side) end up that lack the scientific rigor necessary for the top-tier journals.

Also, FYI, political science has a pretty contentious divide between people who favor a scientific approach and those who prefer a normative/philosophical approach. The two sides basically hate each other. So to claim that "In political science - they assert this is science" pretty much misses half of the story.

Re:How Dystopian Fiction Shapes Political Attitudes by Emma_Goldman on Friday November 30, 2018 @04:34AM (#18567864)
I don't like the paper and think it's horribly crude.

But Perspectives on Politics is a good journal.