News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Chaos Makes the Multiverse Unnecessary by whatshisface on Thursday November 29, 2018 @08:12PM (#18565757)
>Noson S. Yanofsky has a Ph.D. in mathematics from The Graduate Center of The City University of New York. He is a professor of computer science at Brooklyn College of The City University of New York.

Remember the old stereotype[0] of physicists that thought that because they understood physics, they were automatically experts in every field - and so began dispensing "wisdom" to all of the actual experts?

I guess physicists aren't the only ones who are susceptible to this.

[0] http://www.smbc-comics.com/comic/2012-03-21

Re:Chaos Makes the Multiverse Unnecessary by mjfl on Sunday December 02, 2018 @06:37PM (#18585296)
I think this argument, while true in some cases, is overly dismissive in general. The whole imperative to "stay in your lane" is one of the most destructive developments in modern science. In biology, for example, the field of synthetic biology was initiated by two physicists: Michael Elowitz and James Collins. It has since illuminated foundational biological ideas about the nature and purpose of stochasticity and dynamics of gene expression, perspectives that biolgists wouldn't have captured because they aren't used to thinking about things stochastically or dynamically. I actually think there CAN be cross talk back from biology: physicists, in general, have terrible experimental instincts compared to biologists. There's a huge stagnation in physics because we've chosen maximally difficult experimental means to prove small things over long time scales. Any biologist could tell you that you want to pick simple, cheap experiments that will be resolved over a short time period. Only recently are particle physicists tuning into this perspective, with the recent move to emphasize tabletop experiments.

But no, apparently we should all stay in our lanes and respect experts in different fields to know everything. It's DESTRUCTIVE and DISGUSTING.

Re:Chaos Makes the Multiverse Unnecessary by nyc111 on Friday November 30, 2018 @02:05AM (#18567319)
Thanks for sharing this cartoon! This phenomenon is not limited to physicists either, it is pretty much true for all professionals and famous people. But also, physicists claim that they do not deal in philosophy, yet the main subject matter of theoretical physics is a collection of old philosophical subjects such as time, space, the cosmos and absolute beginnings of things. There is a confusion here.

This article makes important points about the relation of physics and mathematics. I agree that physicists pick and choose "smooth" and solvable system and then claim to reveal the secrets of the universe.

Re:Chaos Makes the Multiverse Unnecessary by whatshisface on Friday November 30, 2018 @07:35AM (#18568621)
>But also, physicists claim that they do not deal in philosophy, yet the main subject matter of theoretical physics is a collection of old philosophical subjects such as time, space, the cosmos and absolute beginnings of things.

Geometry used to be studied exclusively by philosophers, but after a long string of successes the group of people who specialized in it got renamed to "mathematicians." Likewise at one point natural science was called "natural philosophy." Philosophy is the mother of the sciences but once the kids get established they move out of the house.

>physicists pick and choose "smooth" and solvable system and then claim to reveal the secrets of the universe.

If you are looking for knowledge about the universe, one hundred percent of it will be found in the form of "ideas comprehensible to humans." All of the secrets of the universe that we know are obviously going to be the knowable ones. If you spend time studying things that aren't knowable then by definition you are wasting your time, even if there is an ontological category of "unknowable but true."

Re:Chaos Makes the Multiverse Unnecessary by throwawaymath on Thursday November 29, 2018 @09:16PM (#18566052)
I'm not following your point. Are you saying you think the author is not qualified to write about the article's topic?
Re:Chaos Makes the Multiverse Unnecessary by whatshisface on Thursday November 29, 2018 @09:20PM (#18566068)
I'm pointing out the humor in the fact that the tables have turned on physicsts that do what the author is doing, because now someone is doing it to them.