This is about deciding which kind of city you want and building the transportation options that fit that environment. Cities built for cars are very different from cities built for density and walkability. You can’t compare the two modes devoid of that context.
Raising the price of gas negatively affects the working poor more than helps the environment. That subset of society may not live in an area accessible by transit, or their employment requires them to be in a different location than is feasible to travel to by transit.
In the short run. In the long run, the proceeds could be used to encourage the working poor to move to cities where they don't need a car. Given how financially terrible car ownership is for America's poor--between traffic tickets, civil forfeiture, police violence, predatory lending and collection practices, insurance practices, et cetera--I think it would be a net boon.
Gas taxes can be raised in a way that is neutral to our working poor. It's a minor adjustment to the lowest tax bracket.
If we funneled as much money to mass transit as we do to vehicle infrastructure, there'd be no competition.
See how that feels?
> live in Manhattan
You and I have had very different experiences with the subway over the last year.
"The average American commute crept up to 26.4 minutes in 2015" [1]. In New York City, the "average one-way commute [is] almost 36 minutes" [2], with "a major gap" being in the realm of "12 minutes of delay" [3]. Compared to mean American traffic delays, New York at its worst is many other cities on a good day.
[1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2017/02/22/the-a...
[2] https://www.nytimes.com/2018/02/22/realestate/commuting-best...
[3] https://ibo.nyc.ny.us/iboreports/we-are-being-held-momentari...
Many people commute by car to a park and ride and then by train and then by subway. Any delay anywhere in the system causes major downstream problems.
Sorry, I was contrasting non-driving commute outside New York to New York City mass transit commuting. Originally, density--à la NYC--was suggested as a solution. Someone responded by trashing the MTA's history of delays. Hence my comment. Driving in and around New York City is frustrating, unreliable and expensive.
If you want to see transit done right, go to Tokyo. People have sub-hour commutes of over 100 miles there. Everything is comfortable, clean and on-time. If we honestly want to make public transport succeed, we have to stop letting those in charge compare themselves to other failures and, instead, hold them accountable to operating at a level we know is being achieved elsewhere.
> But these stats don't capture how many of the 97% hated commuting by car but had to
> 97 percent of our folks were arriving by themselves in a car
Emphasis mine. Cars carrying just one person to and from work every day is a waste.
How big is the percent of population in Chicago live so far from the downtown that they need a transport to commute?
The population of the Chicago metropolitan area i.e. "Chicagoland" is 9.5 million (almost the size of Michigan). So 6.7 million people are technically not in the city.
A significant fraction of them commute to downtown Chicago for work.
That's really a lot, 70%! How big of a portion of them are commuting to downtown?
Anecdotally, as someone whose walk to work (from other transit) takes them against the flow of people coming from Union Station: it's a lot of people indeed.
September 2018 Metra ridership report: https://metrarail.com/sites/default/files/assets/planning/ri...
All reports: https://metrarail.com/about-metra/reports-documents/operatio...
Shenzhen has twice as many people as Chicago. So, if we extrapolate, the amount of people commuting will double for Chicago if Chicago were to be turned into Shenzhen.
That tells that much, much, more people in Chicago work outside of urban centre, or the portion of population who is working is simply less.
The U.S. has 1/4 of China's populations, Chicago is the 3rd largest metro area in the U.S. It has a population comparable to Qingdao, but it's relative influence in the country is similar to Chongqing or Hangzhou.
OF COURSE almost every commutes to downtown Chicago by transit, because parking costs are insane.
I'm not saying I'm not pro-transit; I am. Very much so. But these stats don't capture how many of the 97% hated commuting by car but had to, and how many of the 90% "non-automobile" commutes are being done by people grudgingly (or AFTER driving a car to a train station, paying for parking, waiting for a train, and wishing they had a nice big free parking lot at their destination).