News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Competition Is Dying, and Taking Capitalism with It? by thwy12321 on Wednesday November 28, 2018 @11:06PM (#18558003)
Big tech companies arent really monopolies. A ton of them can disappear overnight, its just a trendy thing to harp on. Look at the irrelevance of IBM, CISCO, HP, Intel, Oracle, etc. The list goes on and on, companies fail to innovate after a certain point and most die. Enough with the monopoly narrative.
Re:Competition Is Dying, and Taking Capitalism with It? by nanny on Wednesday November 28, 2018 @11:09PM (#18558023)
Are you trying to say that because a company can disappear overnight, it isn't currently a monopoly? Because I don't think that makes any sense.
Re:Competition Is Dying, and Taking Capitalism with It? by BurningFrog on Wednesday November 28, 2018 @11:34PM (#18558132)
The danger of a monopoly is supposed to be that it can crush all competition, and stay a monopoly forever.

If monopolies can routinely be outcompeted, then what is there to be concerned about with them?

Re:Competition Is Dying, and Taking Capitalism with It? by jakelazaroff on Thursday November 29, 2018 @12:55AM (#18558397)
The danger of a monopoly lies in its ability to exploit a market, not in its longevity.

Markets can change in ways that destroy monopolies. For example, if in 1900 you had a monopoly on horse-drawn carriages, that wouldn't have prevented you from being put out of business by the advent of the automobile.

Re:Competition Is Dying, and Taking Capitalism with It? by BurningFrog on Friday November 30, 2018 @11:46AM (#18570351)
You know that's a good point. Thanks!

I think the distinction is between a monopoly disappearing because the market it owns disappears, or because it gets outcompeted in it.

Re:Competition Is Dying, and Taking Capitalism with It? by thwy12321 on Wednesday November 28, 2018 @11:17PM (#18558064)
I'm saying that its true that some are monopolies, but none really stay that way for long, and so its completely overrated to worry about. It's a similar talking point to how we are in an "AI bubble", good for clicks on an article.

Look at FB stock, it just dropped from 220 -> ~130, they saw almost half of their market cap wiped away in a few weeks. The monopoly idea is a narrative invented to stoke fear, outrage, and page clicks. It's a talking point for psuedo educated people.

Re:Competition Is Dying, and Taking Capitalism with It? by msiyer on Wednesday November 28, 2018 @11:53PM (#18558198)
Monopolies, whether ephemeral or eternal, are bad. Disappearance of a monopoly does not mean the data collected disappears nor does it repair the torn social fabric.
Re:Competition Is Dying, and Taking Capitalism with It? by afjl on Wednesday November 28, 2018 @11:53PM (#18558199)
I entirely disagree. Monopolies discourage innovation and creativity. American companies do not operate in some bubble; we have to remain competitive with the outside world, with countries that would seek to erode our competitive advantage. Internal competition is a great way to ensure that we do not fall behind others.

I also don't think bringing up FB's stock price is relevant, not sure what your point is getting at there?

Re:Competition Is Dying, and Taking Capitalism with It? by inetknght on Wednesday November 28, 2018 @11:19PM (#18558068)
> Look at the irrelevance of IBM, CISCO, HP, Intel, Oracle, etc.

I'm real curious how you think those companies are irrelevant.

Re:Competition Is Dying, and Taking Capitalism with It? by thwy12321 on Wednesday November 28, 2018 @11:23PM (#18558093)
They were once the big bad "monopolies". Now they're just mediocre companies. Weird how manipulated people can be by narratives. Show me any company who has dominated for 50 years, thats something to worry about. Both FB and Google could lose 50% of their value in a month. See the recent FB stock drop. Its a complete fallacy, a trendy thought narrative, its propaganda.