News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Students Evaluating Teachers Doesn’t Just Hurt Teachers, ... by olliej on Wednesday November 28, 2018 @06:56PM (#18556848)
In America teachers get tenure so your feedback has no impact on them improving.

Also if you look at literally any study of them TAs for harder courses get harsher ratings, they get harsher ratings from weaker students.

I also spent a number of years as a TA I can say anecdotally that is my exact first hand experience - good reviews in easy courses like graphics, atrocious scores in design of concurrent systems. In fact for concurrent systems it was well known that the TA for the course would literally always get the lowest review rating in the department, and that was independent of their rating in any other courses that they TAd.

TAs also get punished if the actual instructor is bad - because students blame everyone in the course.

I mean the American system has its own slew of problems - lecturers run the tests themselves, they by design don’t provide prior exams (hint: if knowing the prior years exam questions tells you enough to be considered your exams are bad and you should feel bad)

Re:Students Evaluating Teachers Doesn’t Just Hurt Teachers, ... by Y7ZCQtNo39 on Wednesday November 28, 2018 @07:04PM (#18556900)
Very few professors are granted tenure, as was the case in the past. It's weakly non-zero: times have changed. There are far more adjunct professors today. Universities are more run like businesses than in decades past.
Re:Students Evaluating Teachers Doesn’t Just Hurt Teachers, ... by bocklund on Thursday November 29, 2018 @12:02AM (#18558237)
I don’t have data, but I think most tenure track professors get tenure (if not at their current university, than another).

Adjunct professors are not tenure track, so there is really no expectation that they would get tenure. Though I have seen the numbers that say the number of adjuncts is increasing.

Re:Students Evaluating Teachers Doesn’t Just Hurt Teachers, ... by vonmoltke on Thursday November 29, 2018 @07:58AM (#18559837)
The point is that far fewer professors are tenure track to begin with, compared to past decades.
Re:Students Evaluating Teachers Doesn’t Just Hurt Teachers, ... by olliej on Thursday November 29, 2018 @02:44PM (#18563271)
Almost every lecturer my wife has is tenure track or already tenured.

One of them just plays videos of himself in his lectures. He doesn't actually go to them. He is actually around during less than half of his scheduled office hours. He complains to (and at least once has shouted at) the TAs about how students keep asking him questions. He has tenure.

Re:Students Evaluating Teachers Doesn’t Just Hurt Teachers, ... by DrJosiah on Thursday November 29, 2018 @01:06AM (#18558422)
As a former TA for one of the "bad" professors, you can somewhat rescue your rating, but you basically have to be a hero, and the professor needs to not be malicious (if the prof wants to fail everyone, not a lot you can do).

You have to attend every lecture (I did anyway), redirect / fix during discussion / lab, help them learn what they need to know to pass the exams, and if you have time, what they should remember when the term is over for their future academic / work careers.

Only bad ratings I recall were from students who only attended the last discussion section; it's hard to teach 10 weeks of theoretical CS in 50 minutes.

Re:Students Evaluating Teachers Doesn’t Just Hurt Teachers, ... by dual_basis on Saturday December 01, 2018 @01:32PM (#18578080)
Ohhhh, I thought that's what "CS50" meant!
Re:Students Evaluating Teachers Doesn’t Just Hurt Teachers, ... by tgb on Wednesday November 28, 2018 @09:45PM (#18557629)
Not my experience - being a TA for a bad professor or bad course involved more work but gets one better evaluations. You're the "good guy". If the professor is good, the standards are higher and you can't leave their shadow.
Re:Students Evaluating Teachers Doesn’t Just Hurt Teachers, ... by pmiller2 on Thursday November 29, 2018 @02:18AM (#18558638)
> TAs also get punished if the actual instructor is bad - because students blame everyone in the course.

You think that's bad, try being instructor of record for a remedial math course as a TA.

Re:Students Evaluating Teachers Doesn’t Just Hurt Teachers, ... by eagsalazar2 on Wednesday November 28, 2018 @09:31PM (#18557576)
It would be easy enough to normalize for those trends right? (seems like a solvable problem)
Re:Students Evaluating Teachers Doesn’t Just Hurt Teachers, ... by anticensor on Thursday November 29, 2018 @05:07AM (#18559177)
> they by design don’t provide prior exams

Do they reuse past questions forever? That is a bad practice. Each term's exams need to be equivalent but different.

Re:Students Evaluating Teachers Doesn’t Just Hurt Teachers, ... by olliej on Thursday November 29, 2018 @12:44PM (#18562033)
The way to ensure that they’re different is to require all prior assessment be publicly available - if someone having access to an old exam gives them an unfair advantage over people who don’t then that’s bad design.
Re:Students Evaluating Teachers Doesn’t Just Hurt Teachers, ... by anticensor on Thursday November 29, 2018 @04:52PM (#18564432)
I suspected that, and asked for clarification.
Re:Students Evaluating Teachers Doesn’t Just Hurt Teachers, ... by olliej on Thursday November 29, 2018 @04:59PM (#18564506)
Oh sorry I interpreted it as a hypothetical or something :)

My interpretation of the way US lecturers work is that they may reuse entire exams. Especially as a lot just get exams from book publishers.

In NZ (at Canterbury at least) all exams are archived and available in the libraries, and most also as PDFs. All of them. Shelf after shelf stretching back decades. At least back when I was there - maybe it’s different now? Publishers selling exam material as part of their text books seems to be moderately recent

Re:Students Evaluating Teachers Doesn’t Just Hurt Teachers, ... by eastWestMath on Wednesday November 28, 2018 @10:06PM (#18557707)
It can be even worse - I’ve seen TAs who basically serve up assignment solutions trying to get high ratings.