Re:Sheep Or How Google is destroying the internet
by shabda on Friday May 09, 2008 @01:14PM
(#185656)
For starters,
http://www.forbes.com/2007/06/28/negative-search-google-tech...
I am sort of lazy right now finding replies to [citation needed], but read threadwatch.oorg, I am sure can find a few.
Re:Sheep Or How Google is destroying the internet
by mechanical_fish on Friday May 09, 2008 @03:01PM
(#185757)
Well, that's very interesting. Although this article is merely a pro-journalism example of the very same "consider the case of sites X and Y, where X and Y are cannot be named" phenomenon, so it still isn't clear to me how large the risk is.
And I'm with justindz, who doesn't understand the proposed defense. If a competitor decides to cross the ethical line and take your site down by "generously" having spambots put up links to your site, thereby causing Google to conclude that you're a spammer and shut down your pagerank... can't they do this to all of your sites at once, not just one? My understanding -- correct me if I'm wrong -- is that the cost or supply of spambots is not the limiting factor here.
But if the sites are similar and are created for safe redundancy, I would assume the second site is going to imminently get nailed as well. I mean, the guys says build two of the same sites at different places so you have a backup. You're building two mediocre targets either hoping that the other one isn't noticed by google (which probably means users aren't finding it either) or that they're significantly different somehow.
I agree, it sounds in its lack of detail like someone doing something sketchy and complaining it doesn't work. I'm not aware of any cases in which non-specious websites have gotten nailed and had no recourse. The author didn't provide any. Has anyone seen this in the wild?