News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Magnus Carlsen Beats Fabiano Caruana to Win World Chess C... by nevi-me on Wednesday November 28, 2018 @02:56PM (#18555054)
Well, their ELOs are just about the same, so I agree with the spirit of your viewpoint.

I'd argue that he's better because he has mastered more than just one format. If we have a tie in one category, and one of the players has a strong advantage in another category; then they'll come out as "better".

Re:Magnus Carlsen Beats Fabiano Caruana to Win World Chess C... by umanwizard on Wednesday November 28, 2018 @03:29PM (#18555342)
To someone (like the person you replied to) who considers slow chess to be "actual chess" and quicker formats to be a different game, this argument doesn't make sense.

Imagine two people of equal ability at ice hockey. You wouldn't say that one is better than the other at ice hockey because he's better than the other at field hockey.

Adding my edit to a below comment here:

Probably the best analogy here is association football -- the normal, standard game can end in a draw. During the World Cup and other elimination tournaments, a completely new rule, not part of the normal game, is introduced allowing games to be decided by penalty kicks. Is the fact that Italy beat France in the 2006 World Cup final on penalty kicks evidence that Italy's team was "better at association football" than France's? Many people would argue that it's not.

Re:Magnus Carlsen Beats Fabiano Caruana to Win World Chess C... by joefkelley on Wednesday November 28, 2018 @03:40PM (#18555445)
Would you consider an ice hockey player's skill in 3-on-3 overtime or shootouts to be a factor in their overall ice hockey skill?
Re:Magnus Carlsen Beats Fabiano Caruana to Win World Chess C... by umanwizard on Wednesday November 28, 2018 @03:57PM (#18555618)
Sure -- overtime is part of the rules of hockey. Rapid and blitz chess aren't part of the rules of standard chess.

Rapid and blitz (and armageddon) were part of the meta-rules of this match, but then your argument only works if you say Magnus is better at the meta-sport called "winning the 2018 World Chess Championship" -- which I'd agree with, but it isn't the same thing as being better at chess.

Probably the best analogy here is association football -- the normal, standard game can end in a draw. During the World Cup and other elimination tournaments, a completely new rule, not part of the normal game, is introduced allowing games to be decided by penalty kicks. Is the fact that Italy beat France in the 2006 World Cup final on penalty kicks evidence that Italy's team was "better at association football" than France's? Many people would argue that it's not.

Re:Magnus Carlsen Beats Fabiano Caruana to Win World Chess C... by patejam on Wednesday November 28, 2018 @05:28PM (#18556267)
Overtime is basically meta-rules as well in ice hockey. It can change depending on the game. ex. it differs depending on if its a playoff game or not. And just like the chess championships, it can change from year to year.

I've competed at a high level in a hobby of mine, and it was well known that the winner of a competition was never "the person who is best", it was "the person who is best in the competition environment that day". No matter what rules you have, that will always be true. And that's okay.

Re:Magnus Carlsen Beats Fabiano Caruana to Win World Chess C... by fosco on Wednesday November 28, 2018 @03:41PM (#18555450)
albeit, if there were shorter time constraints for each period, I would say the team that wins in that smaller time constraint is better even though the meta changes, it becomes less a game of endurance and more a game of holding peak performance as long as possible. imagine 4 minute periods. it definitely changes the game but it is still all in all the game, goals are still scored the same way. (please note, I know extremely little about hockey... but I think the analogy works, if it doesn't please let me know.)
Re:Magnus Carlsen Beats Fabiano Caruana to Win World Chess C... by ubernostrum on Wednesday November 28, 2018 @04:56PM (#18556054)
Quick reminder that it's "Elo", not "ELO". It's not an acronym or initialism. It's named after its inventor:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arpad_Elo

Re:Magnus Carlsen Beats Fabiano Caruana to Win World Chess C... by Bud on Wednesday November 28, 2018 @06:34PM (#18556716)
Always important to avoid ambiguity with Electric Light Orchestra. ;)
Re:Magnus Carlsen Beats Fabiano Caruana to Win World Chess C... by fileeditview on Wednesday November 28, 2018 @03:21PM (#18555261)
Their ELOs are currently about the same but Carlsen is on that level(and higher) for a long time whereas Caruana and a few others have just come close.

I wouldn't be surprised if Carlsen would soon again have a comfortable lead on the ELO ladder. He was once at 2882.

I am however happy that he had such a worthy opponent in this tournament!

Re:Magnus Carlsen Beats Fabiano Caruana to Win World Chess C... by nevi-me on Wednesday November 28, 2018 @03:35PM (#18555383)
Interestingly, he has a wider gap on rapid and blitz, again showing the magnitude of his strength