News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Outrage Over Human Gene Editing Will Fade Fast by fwip on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @08:03PM (#18548387)
This paragraph rings hollow: "Other examples of human variability, such as intelligence, would be even harder to change with current editing techniques. We can’t even produce a consistent definition of intelligence, much less identify its genetic determinants."

Even if we can't tell for sure what effect a particular genetic edit will have, telling customers "Yes this should make your baby smarter" is enough to convince a lot of people.

Also, the risks of off-target editing is massively understated - the FDA is reluctant to allow clinical trials for CRISPR-based therapy in consenting adults, requiring thorough evidence that you've catalogued and proved safe all off-target effects.

Here is a better article from actual scientists: https://www.statnews.com/2015/11/17/gene-editing-embryo-cris...

Re:Outrage Over Human Gene Editing Will Fade Fast by analog31 on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @09:02PM (#18548665)
Likewise "yes this investment should beat the market."

My guess is that, given the ability for quacks and hucksters to outnumber legitimate practitioners, the results of gene editing will suffer a signal-to-noise problem for years if not decades to come. Even if some particular treatment is proven, it will be set aside if someone else offers a better but unproven treatment.

Re:Outrage Over Human Gene Editing Will Fade Fast by devoply on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @08:50PM (#18548615)
Human beings become like nature, get ready for potential failures similar to hereditary defects affecting millions of people. Biology is a kluge, and humans trying to mess with biology is a much bigger kluge as we are like hackers messing with a very complicated machine by screwing with a few of its transistors to affect how the code that runs on it functions. We don't know wtf we are doing.