News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Outrage Over Human Gene Editing Will Fade Fast by darawk on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @07:58PM (#18548370)
Completely agree. This has always been a fabricated issue anyway. People enhance themselves all sorts of ways, diet exercise, tutoring, etc.

The hysteria over genetic engineering will last just as long as it takes for the first few successful attempts to show their benefits, and then everyone will promptly forget it was ever an issue at all.

Re:Outrage Over Human Gene Editing Will Fade Fast by untog on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @08:24PM (#18548491)
Yes, but genes are one of the last equalisers out there. To an extent, obviously - your genes come from your parents - but rich and poor alike have both benefitted and suffered from their genetic makeups. Before long genetic engineering will be commonplace but almost exclusively among the rich. Arguably, much like dieting, exercise and tutoring.
Re:Outrage Over Human Gene Editing Will Fade Fast by daemonk on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @09:07PM (#18548692)
Maybe a more relevant analogy are medical procedures. IE. Banning specialized brain or heart surgery because only rich people can afford it.
Re:Outrage Over Human Gene Editing Will Fade Fast by speby on Wednesday November 28, 2018 @12:56AM (#18549584)
Perhaps. And like salt in ancient times, there are luxuries of the rich that eventually, become less expensive and more accessible to people of more modest means. I can see that being the case for genetic engineering too. Consider that the first genome sequencing (the human genome project) cost around $2.7 billion dollars in the 90s (https://www.genome.gov/11006943/human-genome-project-complet...). These days, you can do a full sequenincing of your DNA (not like the 23andme style) for around $1,400 (https://www.genome.gov/11006943/human-genome-project-complet...).
Re:Outrage Over Human Gene Editing Will Fade Fast by PavlovsCat on Wednesday November 28, 2018 @05:26AM (#18550498)
> there are luxuries of the rich that eventually, become less expensive and more accessible to people of more modest means

Inequality is rising, not falling.

For example, any person at all today can easily get their hands on weapon that would win them any fight with a caveman wielding a bone, sure. But today, there's tanks and satellites and whatnot -- the most powerless became WAY more powerless in contras to the most powerful. You don't compare the poor of today with the rich of yesterday, you compare the them with the rich of today. And you compare the poor of tomorrow with the rich of tomorrow.

> Rifles, muskets, long-bows and hand-grenades are inherently democratic weapons. A complex weapon makes the strong stronger, while a simple weapon - so long as there is no answer to it - gives claws to the weak.

-- George Orwell

Already it's pretty normal for rich people to consider themselves above socializing with poor people. Adding editing of genes on top of that might not just turn that wide gap into a fortified moat, complete with property rights and patents and enforcement of said patents (imagine getting a mutation by chance that you have no license for), it might also mess up the incentives for medical research even more.

Why find a cure for a disease that anyone can get, that is another "equalizer", when you can immunize yourself and your offspring to it? You may say all such things will always be made available to everybody, but how would you know now? What of the current behaviour of the powerful gives you reason to consider that likely? When it comes to biodiversity and the possibility of extinction, not many HN comments mention the people with the biggest footprints, but a lot mention "overpopulation". So how would that mesh with making the unwashed masses more resilient and healthy? Wouldn't it make more sense to go the opposite way? You see, "perhaps" isn't good enough with something like this. At these speeds, "eventually" steering means crashing into a wall.

Re:Outrage Over Human Gene Editing Will Fade Fast by docbrown on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @08:44PM (#18548594)
>Before long genetic engineering will be commonplace but almost exclusively among the rich.

I think we’ve already fell into this type of scenario and I think this is partially why some are so against it. They’re looking at this as an luxury to families but if done right, gene engineering could and should be used solely to protect against inheritable and community spread diseases. This type of engineering can be a massive breakthrough for developing countries and similar areas.

But looking at this from a realistic standpoint: genetic engineering will be a taboo extreme that only a few will ever be successful with—until it is internationally recognized as beneficial and properly regulated.

Re:Outrage Over Human Gene Editing Will Fade Fast by darawk on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @08:42PM (#18548582)
True, but my point is that banning genetic engineering will seem as silly as banning tutoring. You don't ban the ability to improve yourself because some people might use it to be better than others.
Re:Outrage Over Human Gene Editing Will Fade Fast by darawk on Wednesday November 28, 2018 @03:13PM (#18555185)
> Yes, but genes are one of the last equalisers out there.

Are they equalisers though? And what makes you think gene editing won't be available to everyone? It seems like the sort of thing with an exponential cost curve. It will very rapidly become cheap and accessible to all.

In fact, i'd argue it's likely to be more equalizing than inequalizing.

Re:Outrage Over Human Gene Editing Will Fade Fast by dragonwriter on Wednesday November 28, 2018 @03:22PM (#18555268)
> And what makes you think gene editing won't be available to everyone? It seems like the sort of thing with an exponential cost curve. It will very rapidly become cheap and accessible to all.

The rich and already disproportionately powerful will get it and use it first (creating barriers to upward mobility and exacerbating class power divides), then will have every incentive (and even more disproportionate power than previously) to create barriers to access.

Similar to the reason that, 70+ years later, there are only a handful of nuclear weapons states.

Re:Outrage Over Human Gene Editing Will Fade Fast by darawk on Friday November 30, 2018 @04:57PM (#18573077)
You mean like how they did with the iPhone? Where exactly has that ever happened for any nontrivial period of time? Technology gets pushed to the masses. The rich will get richer by selling it to them not keeping it for themselves.
Re:Outrage Over Human Gene Editing Will Fade Fast by eloff on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @08:37PM (#18548563)
The rich will always have advantages. Technology just gives them more. But it's up to the state to level the field if and where appropriate. Currently the US is dead last among developed nations in doing this.
Re:Outrage Over Human Gene Editing Will Fade Fast by darawk on Friday November 30, 2018 @04:58PM (#18573082)
Yes, but the field shouldn't be leveled by holding all of humanity back. That's silly. It should be leveled by giving everyone access to the technology.
Re:Outrage Over Human Gene Editing Will Fade Fast by sytelus on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @09:54PM (#18548911)
Gene modifications slips in to rest of the population, other changes don't. You can think of every human being as virus out to infect others with its genes ;).

Given how so many parents are desperate about their kids to succeed in the super-competitive world, this is bound to become a trend - especially in middle class population who have money for the procedure but aren't rich. In China, Japan, there is cutthroat fight for getting in best schools, be the most attractive etc. These parents are also very easy to be mislead with incorrect/incomplete information.

Re:Outrage Over Human Gene Editing Will Fade Fast by darawk on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @10:11PM (#18548993)
Ya but so what? I feel like people often say something like what you said, but I don't really see the dystopian future that its supposed to invoke.
Re:Outrage Over Human Gene Editing Will Fade Fast by PavlovsCat on Wednesday November 28, 2018 @05:01AM (#18550413)
When will the hysteria over the "hysteria" end, and the actual discussion begin? If one side leads into it with just smearing the other as "hysteric", they don't win, they forfeit.
Re:Outrage Over Human Gene Editing Will Fade Fast by Terribledactyl on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @09:58PM (#18548930)
I agree with the fabricated outrage but there is an interesting difference between diet, exercise, tutoring. Your descendents also get your enhancement for free. (Or at least 50% off)
Re:Outrage Over Human Gene Editing Will Fade Fast by naasking on Wednesday November 28, 2018 @12:32AM (#18549503)
Actually, lifestyle choices can be transmitted to kids via epigenetic factors. Not to mention that wealth is also heritable.
Re:Outrage Over Human Gene Editing Will Fade Fast by orblivion on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @08:52PM (#18548620)
Since you're so certain all of these philosophical issues are silly, could you explain why we care to propagate our species (and not some other species) to begin with?
Re:Outrage Over Human Gene Editing Will Fade Fast by darawk on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @08:56PM (#18548644)
Which philosophical issues are you talking about?
Re:Outrage Over Human Gene Editing Will Fade Fast by orblivion on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @09:02PM (#18548664)
"Once we do this, we're no longer human." Perhaps for some people, this takes the form of "this is playing God".

EDIT: What hysteria were you talking about?

Re:Outrage Over Human Gene Editing Will Fade Fast by darawk on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @09:10PM (#18548701)
> "Once we do this, we're no longer human." Perhaps for some people, this takes the form of "this is playing God".

I think the burden of proof is on the person asserting that to say why it is so. We alter ourselves in lots of ways, why is this different?

> EDIT: What hysteria were you talking about?

All the scientists condemning this as terrible, and articles written about the dystopian future it portends.

Re:Outrage Over Human Gene Editing Will Fade Fast by orblivion on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @09:22PM (#18548754)
> We alter ourselves in lots of ways, why is this different?

This is a fair question. And I've had philosophical problems taking psychiatric drugs, for that matter. (I think it's resolved to some extent by considering that lots of substances we ingest all the time are psychoactive. So it's part of the normal human experience.)

I would say this - Whatever modification you make, you have to come up with a line, a standard, for which you argue "this is still a human." I draw that line at deliberate engineering of genetics. What is yours? Are there some genes that still shouldn't be edited? Maybe you could draw some line there?

OR, if you think that's a silly question and don't care about what is or isn't a human, let's revisit the equally silly assumption that we should care about propagating the human race. I personally feel like if you take such a nihilistic approach to the definition of human, you may as well go all the way and adopt an anti-natalist position. It's just not clear any more what game we're playing.

> All the scientists condemning this as terrible, and articles written about the dystopian future it portends.

Interesting, I'd expect scientists to be on the pro-side of this. I don't know have a strong opinion on the consequential outcomes.

(Made some edits above)

Re:Outrage Over Human Gene Editing Will Fade Fast by hackinthebochs on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @10:06PM (#18548973)
I just don't see the value in staying within some arbitrarily defined bound of "human". If anything, humanity is exemplified by our ability to manipulate nature to our benefit. Genetic engineering doesn't seem substantively different to me.

I also don't see how this relates to the instinct to procreate. We don't procreate because we think its the "human" thing to do, we do it because we're human and we have an instinct to procreate. If procreation conflicted with some other drive or interest of ours, we might decide to forgo it (and many do). But this doesn't seem out of bounds of what is typically human either.

Re:Outrage Over Human Gene Editing Will Fade Fast by orblivion on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @10:25PM (#18549063)
It's not that it's a human thing to do. It's that we're generally interested in producing more humans. More particularly, more members our our own family. In that sense, a sense of humanity matters.