There are plenty of practical grounds too. They don’t just turn off the cancer switch - gene editing ‘turns off’ some deep cellular function that is involved in cancer developing. But that function might regulate something else we don’t understand - we don’t yet know the consequences 40,50 or 100 years later of doing that.
To determine that some change is safe during the expected 150 year of life, you must measure the effects during … at least 150 years (preferability more).
How would be you sure that there are no tradeoff? Perhaps it reduce the chance of reproduction by a 1%. Perhaps it affect the ability to climb very tall mountains or very deep scuba diving. Perhaps it will make your grandgrandchildren more weak during a famine (sooner or later, some of your descendants will suffer a famine) or an epidemic. What are the good genes for surviving a war? How do you average the advantages and disadvantages of the normal times and the war times? And there are some adaptations that cause problems but makes you more resistant to malaria, how long you expect your descendants to live in a malaria free zone?
How are you sure that the proposed changes are real advantages and not just some fads? (Consider that it's not clear how many eggs should you eat weekly, the recommendation changes every ten years.)
What about exchanging 10 years of life for a 1% more chance of reproduction. Perhaps 1% is small, but it accumulates during the generations.
With respect to the topic under discussion: absent any particular reason to suppose that this kind of gene editing causes your hypothetical wartime probability difference or your hypothetical 1% fertility drop, there's no reason to use the possibility of these effects to ban the treatment, since there's as much reason to believe you're making these things less likely as reason to believe that you're making these things more likely.
Regarding changes being advantages: do you really believe, deep down, that being weak is just as useful as being strong? That being resistant to disease is just as good as being vulnerable? That being dumb is just as good as being a genius? Give me a break: I can't seriously entertain the idea that we don't know which traits we'd want our children to have, given a choice.
Can you explain?
1) never had the need of this experiment, it was not to cure him but to test the effect of messing with a certain gene.
2) we never had its consent (obviously)
I don't know about US, but in EU we don't experiment with people, without their concent and in order not to cure them, but to find how to build a stronger race.
That's a whole higher level of screwed up that just happened in China.
This is non-consenting human experiment in order not to cure but to find how to build a stronger race. This is not (as far as I know) in any way comparable to what is happening in the West
"Involuntary Sterilization and Castration in Sweden and the Nordic Countries"
"In 1934, the first sterilisation act was enacted in Sweden followed by the first castration act in 1944. In 1972, Sweden became the first country in the world to enact legislation for the amendment of legally registered sex, however preconditioned on sterilisation. In the implementation of all these laws, voluntary and involuntary interventions have been made with legislative support... The involuntarily castrated [in the period 1972-2013] have still not received any reparations from the Swedish State [2018]"
https://www.soclaw.lu.se/en/node/394
It seems that authists and trans people were actively targetted for a long period of time.