News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:China Expands Research Funding, Luring U.S. Scientists an... by sctb on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @05:22PM (#18547407)
We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18546130.
Re:China Expands Research Funding, Luring U.S. Scientists an... by amaccuish on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @03:52PM (#18546559)
Where on earth did you get that from? Which part of the article, or any evidence at all, supports your statement? And in what situation do you think it's acceptable to write in such a way?
Re:China Expands Research Funding, Luring U.S. Scientists an... by PavlovsCat on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @05:08PM (#18547304)
> And in what situation do you think it's acceptable to write in such a way?

In what situation do you think it's acceptable to look the other way?

[dead]
Re:China Expands Research Funding, Luring U.S. Scientists an... by sctb on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @05:23PM (#18547415)
We've banned this account for abusing this community with an ideological agenda.

> Please don't use Hacker News primarily for political or ideological battle. This destroys intellectual curiosity, so we ban accounts that do it.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:China Expands Research Funding, Luring U.S. Scientists an... by nyolfen on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @05:00PM (#18547246)
none of those links support your insane claim about genetic experimentation on babies
Re:China Expands Research Funding, Luring U.S. Scientists an... by alabato on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @06:53PM (#18548018)
Indeed it is surely not true that they have camps where they do large scale genetic experimentations on babies... But from what we know they still at least did one such experiment. And this is completely insane and past any most basic ethics to do a non-consenting human experiment that moreover does not even aim to cure him but tries to find out how to build a stronger race.
Re:China Expands Research Funding, Luring U.S. Scientists an... by amaccuish on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @04:26PM (#18546952)
How is this relevent to this article?

Your specific claim was that scientists are being recruited from abroad for work on these things, except, they're not ("Except this time, China is hiring for genetic specialists to experiment on Uighur babies in concentration camps").

Trying to shove some other agenda into anything China-related is becoming really dull. You're trying to start some sort of ideological war when we really should be discussing science funding.

Re:China Expands Research Funding, Luring U.S. Scientists an... by coldtea on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @04:26PM (#18546959)
How on earth do you not know to google? And in what situation do you think it's acceptable to keep asking people to post easily found links?

You can easily find stuff about western gene-editing research and plans, just not a 'me first' for babies:

https://www.technologyreview.com/s/608350/first-human-embryo...

China's cameras? Well, the US is the surveillance champion of the world. Maybe search "snowden". And unlike China, it also violates my privacy as a European.

>"Time to Address China's Expanding Nuclear Weapons Program"

Actual action, not mere "program": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atomic_bombings_of_Hiroshima_a...

And air-pollution? Do you know how US cities were back in the day? Or even today? And that's without being the world's top manufacturer...

https://losangeles.cbslocal.com/2016/08/10/southern-californ...

Re:China Expands Research Funding, Luring U.S. Scientists an... by schoen on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @04:31PM (#18547014)
> And unlike China, it also violates my privacy as a European.

I'm happy to agree that U.S. surveillance activities violate your privacy, but I'm not sure you should say "unlike China" in this context.

Re:China Expands Research Funding, Luring U.S. Scientists an... by coldtea on Wednesday November 28, 2018 @04:31AM (#18550298)
Well, China doesn't get support for European governments, (unlike e.g. the US) to put their surveillance equipment in here, they weren't caught red handed spying on our top politicians (unlike the US), and while they could very well be targeting Chinese targets or people of interest, I'm 100% certain they don't mass track everyone in Europe.
Re:China Expands Research Funding, Luring U.S. Scientists an... by schoen on Wednesday November 28, 2018 @05:46PM (#18556402)
All agreed up until the "100% certain they don't mass track everyone in Europe part"—what's the basis for that strong certainty? That they don't want to, they realize it would be wrong, they don't think it would be worth it, or just that they can't because the European governments aren't facilitating it or looking the other way when they do it?

There are quite a few mass surveillance techniques that don't require support from a local government:

  * undersea cable tapping
  * hacking routers
  * hacking servers
  * bribing people
  * backdooring hardware
  * spy satellites
  * RF surveillance from embassies or shell companies
Several of those seem pretty plausible for me for the PRC to be using against Europeans. :-(
Re:China Expands Research Funding, Luring U.S. Scientists an... by z2 on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @05:13PM (#18547342)
Air quality indices, at least measured in PM2.5 or PM10, seem to be closer to 200-600 for the overwhelming majority of places in Shandong (which I assume is what you meant), currently and for the past 48 hours. I could only find one place [0] exceeding 800. Those levels are already appalling, but your statement suggests that it is 'around 800' for the entire state/province, not that a few locations peaked at 800.

0: http://aqicn.org/city/shandong/caoxian/caoxianwenhuazhongxin...

Re:China Expands Research Funding, Luring U.S. Scientists an... by cdiamand on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @04:16PM (#18546847)
The vast majority of this account's comment history is targeted towards China.
Re:China Expands Research Funding, Luring U.S. Scientists an... by joefranklinsrs on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @04:19PM (#18546879)
only the last few ones :) but hey, please ban me for talking about the urgent issues of the day.
Re:China Expands Research Funding, Luring U.S. Scientists an... by scarcely on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @03:53PM (#18546562)
As a Chinese person the thing I find most dispiriting is that, if this comment had been made in a slightly more subtle and polished way (without a Hitler comparison right at the start, for one thing) it would have received a lot more upvotes and given a lot more credence
Re:China Expands Research Funding, Luring U.S. Scientists an... by guelo on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @04:03PM (#18546714)
Us Americans consider any non democratic government to be immoral and can't imagine putting up with it. Even if the Chinese population is ok with it we still think it's evil. Those are our values.
Re:China Expands Research Funding, Luring U.S. Scientists an... by alabato on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @06:20PM (#18547811)
Well China is doing total surveillance, even the most dystopian sci-fi are now an everyday reality of China, some BlackMirror episode like the one on Social Credit which were meant to be sci-fi are now more of a documentary on China's Score system.

And now China announced they edited a baby's gene not to cure him but just to test if they can buit a new generation of more resistant humans.

Please tell me how this is not completely screwed up ?

(I'm not defending the US, they are in the top of the most mass surveillance countries too, I'm just defending some basic notion like "We should not use non-consenting people as guinea pig to build a stronger race of human" and this kind of stuff...)

Re:China Expands Research Funding, Luring U.S. Scientists an... by Archio on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @04:00PM (#18546659)
I agree that the comparison to Hitler is a non sequitur.

However, as a citizen in a democracy, I am pretty sure the writer of that posts intends it to be a criticism of an authoritarian dictatorship and not China's people or people of Chinese descent.

Re:China Expands Research Funding, Luring U.S. Scientists an... by scarcely on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @04:18PM (#18546870)
I'm sure he's not a monster. Thing is, Americans find it very hard to see us as anything other than monsters. It's exhausting to try and have a conversation when the interlocutor is ready to terminate it at any point because s/he decides that you are either evil or brainwashed. (To me, that's where the real prejudice lies - the inability to imagine other people as moral, not just intellectual, equals)

I should also say that the distinction between "criticizing government" and "criticizing people" is routinely not observed, even by Democrats. When Obama was making a case for the TPP, one of the main argument he gave was "The TPP would let America, not China, lead the way on global trade". Zero-sum language like this sends a signal to Americans that if doing something X is bad for this other group of humans, then that's an argument in favor of doing X, not (crazy thought!) an argument against doing it. That's how you get to where we are now where prominent Democrats like Chuck Schumer can say "we must be united in our fight against the Chinese" and not a single American, liberal or conservative, even took issue with that kind of language.

Re:China Expands Research Funding, Luring U.S. Scientists an... by abecedarius on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @04:38PM (#18547073)
As an American, I'm sorry and I agree with your criticism of that rhetoric.
Re:China Expands Research Funding, Luring U.S. Scientists an... by allendoerfer on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @03:55PM (#18546591)
I wish, people would pick their example dictators for internet discussions from the appropriate magnitude of evilness pot. If you would swap "Hitler" with "Honecker" the point would still be terrifying (surveillance state, human rights violations, unjustified killings and imprisonments) but not as over the top and far away from reality (gigantic genocide).
Re:China Expands Research Funding, Luring U.S. Scientists an... by joefranklinsrs on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @04:09PM (#18546786)
Subjugating a billion people to AQI 600+ for 20 years isn't genocide?

Locking a million muslims up and exterminating them isn't genocide?

"It is actually designed to exterminate — eliminate — the whole Uighur nation as people," he said.

"Children are being removed even when their families are willing to care for them, according to Financial Times Beijing correspondent, Emily Feng."

https://www.abc.net.au/news/2018-09-28/china-working-to-elim...

Re:China Expands Research Funding, Luring U.S. Scientists an... by coldtea on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @04:21PM (#18546907)
>I would look at it a different way: this is akin to Hitler Germany hiring nuclear scientists and eugenics specialists from US.

Well, speaking of "nuclear scientists", only one country has dropped nuclear bombs on civilians, and it wasn't China.

Re:China Expands Research Funding, Luring U.S. Scientists an... by arialeks on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @04:20PM (#18546895)
I am confident that most scientists would never want to work on any of the projects you've mentioned nor could China lure people in to work on such things.

Instead, just the fact that one day China might be the first destination for young talent instead of the US will be enough to give them the edge in their fight for superiority. Whatever the case humanity will see at least some benefit from these type of competitions.

Re:China Expands Research Funding, Luring U.S. Scientists an... by alabato on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @06:08PM (#18547741)
You followed the news right ? They removed a gene from a baby not to cure him but just to experiment and see what's going to happen to him. This absolutely inhumane. This children had scientist messing with his DNA without his consent, just to see if they can create a new generation of more resistant humans. So scientists are perfectly fine with doing inhumane experiments it seems...