News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:The “bicameral mind” 30 years on: A reappraisal of Jaynes... by dang on Sunday November 25, 2018 @06:54PM (#18529879)
This comment breaks two of HN's most important guidelines:

"Please don't post shallow dismissals, especially of other people's work. A good critical comment teaches us something."

"Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize."

If you'd review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and follow the rules when posting here, we'd appreciate it.

Re:The “bicameral mind” 30 years on: A reappraisal of Jaynes... by goto11 on Monday November 26, 2018 @03:39AM (#18531956)
Fair enough, I have elaborated my criticism in other comments. The reference to Hemmingway might seem flippant, but my point was that the Iliad is told in a certain genre or style where thoughts and mental states or not directly described, only events and actions. This is a particular style of narrative which is not confined to a specific stage in human development but exist throughout history, and even today is pretty popular ("show, don't tell"). Movies generally follow this form and voice-overs explaining the characters thoughts are the exception rather than the rule.

So to claim that the narrative style of the Iliad shows that the people does not have a concept of mind and did not have self awareness is just not justified. The narrative style certainly does not prove that, but on the other hand it is impossible to disprove that Achilles lacked consciousness. Which puts this theory into the realm of the nonfalsifiable.

This is akin to the crackpot theory that the ancient Greeks were not able to perceive the color blue, because that word does not occur in Homer. This is just an incredibly naive understanding of the connection between mind and language. While Homeric Greek might not have such a word, there is absolutely no evidence that their sensory system was different.

Furthermore, taking the Iliad as face value is highly problematic. While historians generally agree that there probably was a war, there is no evidence that any of the persons actually existed or existed at the time. The characters might be legendary or mythological. Note that basically all of them descends from gods a few generations back. Achilles is literally half-god. We know that Helen was worshiped as a deity in Sparta for example. If she was actually a mythological figure, we don't really need some complicated psychological theory to explain how one mythological being could talk to another!

So I think it is fair to say the theory have a naive approach to literature.

The second part of the criticism is that the theory does not actually explain anything. The bicameral mind is supposed to explain how people at the time interacted with Gods. It was actually just the other half of the brain giving advice. OK, but the theory also claims that the the integration of the mind happens some time between the composition of the Iliad and the Odyssey (because Odysseys clearly do have a concept of mind with first-person narrative and so on). Which means the theory can't explain the gods appearing in the Odyssey.

Re:The “bicameral mind” 30 years on: A reappraisal of Jaynes... by friendstock on Sunday November 25, 2018 @02:42AM (#18525851)
Jaynes was a professor at Princeton University, so he must've built up enough credibility to get this appointment.

I was a student at Princeton and actually sat in on his class for a few sessions.

Re:The “bicameral mind” 30 years on: A reappraisal of Jaynes... by goto11 on Sunday November 25, 2018 @04:25AM (#18526129)
I'm sure he was credible enough in the field of psychology, but that does not automatically make him an expert in classical literature or religion, which is where he finds the purported evidence for the theory. Therefore the theory have to be judged on its own merit, not just the academic title of the originator.
Re:The “bicameral mind” 30 years on: A reappraisal of Jaynes... by coldtea on Sunday November 25, 2018 @08:59AM (#18526875)
>Jaynes was a professor at Princeton University, so he must've built up enough credibility to get this appointment

Well, Pauling got two Nobel prizes, but still had crackpot theories about Vitamin C

Re:The “bicameral mind” 30 years on: A reappraisal of Jaynes... by rjplatte on Sunday November 25, 2018 @01:59PM (#18528276)
Both Jaynes and Pauling are extremely intelligent and not gullible people. Why are we so quick to dismiss their "Crackpot" theories, simply because they don't fit with the dominant paradigm?
Re:The “bicameral mind” 30 years on: A reappraisal of Jaynes... by goto11 on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @03:26AM (#18540548)
It is quite possible for intelligent people to be wrong, especially when they venture outside their area of expertise.

And the cliche about "dominant paradigm" ignores the actual reasons the theory is rejected. Quantum Theory shows that a theory will be accepted even if fundamentally breaks with the dominant paradigm - as long as it can be confirmed by evidence. So that is not really the issue.

Re:The “bicameral mind” 30 years on: A reappraisal of Jaynes... by coldtea on Sunday November 25, 2018 @05:08PM (#18529376)
Isn't the question taking what it supposed to prove for granted (that we do a facile dismissal of those theories? Who said we didn't do a thorough dismissal?)

Well, is it "simply because they don't fit with the dominant paradigm" or rather because they have been discredited time and again?