News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask YC: How important are HN contribution to YC applicati... by pg on Thursday May 08, 2008 @11:06PM (#185178)
The problem with this kind of approach is that you reward people whose opinions are closest to the average. Those are not the smart people.
Re:Ask YC: How important are HN contribution to YC applicati... by smhinsey on Friday May 09, 2008 @12:54AM (#185224)
You could end up biasing your community towards the mundane (the digg/fark model) if you aren't careful, but what I'm thinking about is something that instead of rewarding people who are "good voters" (for lack of a better term) instead seeks to reward those community members who consistently support high quality contributions.

I define "karma" as a means of valuing your contributions to the community, and it seems that this ought not be dominated simply by what you contribute in a literal sense, but also in what you contribute by encouraging others by voting up their valuable contributions. If our definitions differ, I can see that being the cause of the disagreement.