In other words, saying "it's the definition that we don't have, not the implementation" just pushes the magic smoke around.
I’m saying that I don’t think human intelligence is doing anything more than pattern matching, logical inference and post-hoc justification.
Give me an example of something that falls outside that. There is no magic.
(And no, more GPUs running faster DNNs doesn't seem like an answer.)
The goal is to create AI that can solve any problem a human can solve. Whether sentience is a necessary side effect to that is an open question.
Even in off-chance that you can't improve individual AIs beyond top humans, AI community can be way more intelligent and efficient than humanity, as it is possible to remove the limitations I wrote above. AI society can function as very efficient war economy. War economy shows that even humans can be persuaded/indoctrinated/brought up/whatever to set aside their inessential needs and work for common goal. And AIs will be necessarily more malleable.
So I can't see the idea that AI will be safe by default other than wishful thinking.
I... don't think anyone is arguing that AI is safe in any way? I mean, the pattern matching tools we call AI now are already deployed in very dangerous weapons.
My point is not that AI is going to be safe and warm and fuzzy, or even that it won't be an existential threat. My point is that we're already facing several existential threats that don't require additional technological development to destroy society, and because the existing threats don't require postulating entirely new classes of compute machinery, we should probably focus on them first.
There are still enough nuclear weapons in the world for a global war to end society and most of us. A conflict like we saw in the first half of the 20th century using modern weapons would kill nearly all of us, and we are seeing a global resurgence of early 20th century political ideas. I think this is the biggest danger to the continuation of humanity right now.
We haven't killed ourselves yet... but the danger is still there. we still have apocalyptic weapons aimed and ready to go at a moment's notice. We still face the danger of those weapons becoming cheaper and easier to produce as we advance industrially.
I think humans do way more than that. As the saying goes, "the easiest person to fool is yourself." Humans are able to lie to themselves to the point that they don't realize they are lying to themselves. They're able to create realities that no one else sees but themselves.
But really, I think your idea that we're mostly 'post-hoc justification' is interesting. I mean, I've read some research to that effect, too; but it's... creepy and doesn't line up with anything reasonable about free will or really about long-term planning.
Do they? I don’t (with the possible exception that a definition of AGI itself seems to be this magic smoke)