News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:VLC developer takes a stand against DRM enforcement in Ap... by hasenj on Friday October 29, 2010 @11:14PM (#1849983)
Who's pulling the software out? Apple.
Re:VLC developer takes a stand against DRM enforcement in Ap... by BigZaphod on Friday October 29, 2010 @11:29PM (#1849997)
So who lied, then, when they agreed to Apple's explicitly stated terms and gave Apple permission to distribute VLC in this form in the App Store? If VLC gets removed, it's because this developer is essentially demanding that Apple remove it.
Re:VLC developer takes a stand against DRM enforcement in Ap... by patrickaljord on Friday October 29, 2010 @11:37PM (#1850014)
The dev who is asking to remove it is not the same as the one who submitted it to the appstore. VLC is foss and as such any contributor is a copyright holder and can ask apple to remove it from the appstore.
Re:VLC developer takes a stand against DRM enforcement in Ap... by BigZaphod on Friday October 29, 2010 @11:53PM (#1850036)
I know it's not the same individual that submitted as is making the current complaint.

Whomever agreed to Apple's terms told Apple, by way of agreeing to the contract, that they had full rights and authority to grant Apple the right to distribute the app with all the associated restrictions, etc. outlined in the contract. It would seem that when you consider the terms of the GPL, that person did not have the authority to claim such a thing. That person lied or, at best, was simply mistaken. This isn't Apple's fault. That's all I'm saying. Perhaps ultimately we agree on that point.

Re:VLC developer takes a stand against DRM enforcement in Ap... by hasenj on Saturday October 30, 2010 @01:25AM (#1850184)
You don't get it.

Open apps can't get on the iPhone because Apple disallows it.

Apple is pulling it out, they control what software can or cannot get in. There's no way for anyone to install anything (legally, and without hassle) on the iTouch devices without Apple's permission.

Re:VLC developer takes a stand against DRM enforcement in Ap... by demallien on Saturday October 30, 2010 @06:03AM (#1850573)
No, you don't get it. The fact that VLC was on the App Store is clear proof that Apple has no problem with the GPL. It is the GPL that has a problem with the App Store. Considering that there is plenty of software on the store using other open licenses, such as BSD and LGPL, and putting it together with Apple's willingness to allow GPL'd software(VLC) on the App Store, it is clear that the party causing VLC to be pulled is in fact the copyright holder and no-one else. Claims of "But, but, he made me do it!" are every bit as immature as they sound.
Re:VLC developer takes a stand against DRM enforcement in Ap... by thomasz on Saturday October 30, 2010 @07:41AM (#1850682)
You mean Apple is fine with distributing GPL licensed Software, they just don't want to comply with the licensing terms?
Re:VLC developer takes a stand against DRM enforcement in Ap... by demallien on Saturday October 30, 2010 @08:09AM (#1850710)
Ugh. Is that what you really think that I mean? In case my point wasn't clear enough, I mean to say that Apple doesn't get mixed up in licensing arrangements between app developers and third parties, or if they do, it is just to takedown software that infringes the third party's rights, not to actually comply with the third party's demands

I don't even see how Apple could comply with the licensing terms. They don't have the source code of the app in question, so they can't comply even if they wanted to. Unless you're suggesting that Apple should force every app developer to hand over their source code to Apple, and give Apple the right to distribute it without the developer's agreement? Yeah, that's an attractive deal, I'm sure it'll do wonders for the number of apps in the App Store...

Re:VLC developer takes a stand against DRM enforcement in Ap... by StavrosK on Saturday October 30, 2010 @05:57AM (#1850558)
There definitely is a perfectly legal and convenient way to install anything: jailbreak it and put whatever you want on it.
Re:VLC developer takes a stand against DRM enforcement in Ap... by palish on Saturday October 30, 2010 @06:53AM (#1850629)
Oooh! Someone said "Jailbreak"!

I've been dying to ask: What kinds of awesome things can you do with a jailbroken iPhone? I know you can install VLC + some software to stream videos from some other computer via wifi, which is pretty sweet. What else?

I've been considering Jailbreaking, but it would be cool to have a compelling, shiny reason.

Re:VLC developer takes a stand against DRM enforcement in Ap... by StavrosK on Saturday October 30, 2010 @06:57AM (#1850634)
Re:VLC developer takes a stand against DRM enforcement in Ap... by palish on Saturday October 30, 2010 @07:06AM (#1850643)
Cool! That's definitely shiny!

I can do all of that with my current iPhone anyway though.

Gimme a reason to void the warranty... god knows I want to!

Re:VLC developer takes a stand against DRM enforcement in Ap... by StavrosK on Saturday October 30, 2010 @07:10AM (#1850648)
Wait, how can you do that with an unjailbroken iPhone?
Re:VLC developer takes a stand against DRM enforcement in Ap... by palish on Saturday October 30, 2010 @07:31AM (#1850674)
Well, what you showed, will display:

- any missed calls

- any new voicemails

- and any new text messages.

Each of those, I can check simply by sliding the "unlock" slider.

The daily event isn't really relevant because all events will alert me anyway (because they beep when it's time to do it).

Mail again isn't very relevant.. I'm mostly at a computer all day, I have email open anyway.

The weather I just don't care about.

Apologies for sounding argumentative / etc, I don't mean to! I am merely pointing out that I want to do something cool with a Jailbroken iPhone, something I can't do with my regular iPhone. Else I'll pass. :)

Re:VLC developer takes a stand against DRM enforcement in Ap... by StavrosK on Saturday October 30, 2010 @07:44AM (#1850685)
Ah, well, it doesn't make it magical, it just makes it more useful... For example, my lock button is broken but I can shake to lock it. Otherwise I would be out of luck.
Re:VLC developer takes a stand against DRM enforcement in Ap... by jonhendry on Friday October 29, 2010 @11:31PM (#1849999)
The developer submitted it knowing that Apple's distribution approach was incompatible with the license.

The developer failed. Apple said up front what they'll do for the developer. That doesn't include "whatever you ask us to do".

Apple's completely in the clear. The developer's a moron.