People with school age kids probably vote to approve new funding for school districts at a higher rate than people without kids. Even if the difference is only a couple percent. Is that a scandal? No. Indeed, if nobody had kids, there probably shouldn't be a school. If everybody had kids, why, a good school is an the very heart of the community.
If you really feel that way, charitable organizations can effectively distribute donations far more efficiently and effectively than any government organization has ever been able to. I suspect that if all of the people who say they feel the same way did just voluntarily donate what they considered their own fair share to charity, the homeless crisis would be mostly solved.
1) There's a capability gap. Charities can't do a number of things that are needed that local government can. Simple things like permission to operate portable toilets, or working alongside cops for redirection away from jail it possible, are somewhere between multi-month activities outside their core-competencies to impossible for private actors.
2) The vast bulk of private charities segment their 'market' in various ways that leaves gaps. That's fine, but it isn't going to "mostly solve" the issues caused by society-wide economic failures.
3) Because the problems are so varied, coordination reaps substantial benefits. Social workers talking to cleanup crews talking to mental health talking to cops is a dynamic that your local churches are not equipped to take part in.
Kneejerk antigovernment bias is a national pastime, I know. I'll even play along when it is valid. But the idea that the Salvation Army is going to spring to the rescue is fantasy.
Two, many people don't think rich people should be the ones choosing how we help those in need and who should qualify for that help. Popular causes will get more money, and that often times doesn't line up with what is actually needed.
Third, you seem to completely ignore the problem of collective action. Saying "why don't you just give your own money and leave everyone else alone" is not a way to accomplish things in a society.
If we had an unfettered market perhaps cheap apartments could be built and given to the homeless by charity. In practice new housing that complies with all zoning codes, labor regulations, etc ends up costing quite a lot.
Government certainly has a role to play here even if it is just changing policies to stop driving up costs. Of course governments also have eminent domain power and other powers that private organizations can’t access.
I spent nearly 6 years homeless. I'm currently in an SRO. It is like a million times better.
The hundreds of billions of dollars per year paid out with minimum fuss by Social Security suggest otherwise.
Where it's personally frustrating for me: I've sold two companies in my life, and saw my tax rate jump from the lowest to the highest. I'm fine with that. I did well and despite all the work I put in, I recognize the amount of good fortune that was involved - and I'm perfectly happy to give back more because it affects me less, and because it's my fair share.
I recognize that a lot of others don't feel that way, and certainly recognize the influence that money has on politics. That's sad and frustrating to me.