Sounds like it might even be interesting to the layperson.
https://www.ellenmacarthurfoundation.org/circular-economy/co...
> Draw a control volume around your business or product. If, during the creation, use, or disposal of your product or business, mass or energy crosses this boundary, you should be required to provide for any negative externalities caused by this material or energy.
> Of course, as usual with this approach, the magic is all in the drawing of the boundary, but hear me out.
> Under this framework, it may be a bit easier to see clearly what externalities we might wish to price. I sincerely believe that if we now shrink from this present task of properly pricing and managing these costs, human society will perish from this earth.
Not all negative externalities demand restitution. If you make a better widget, another firm may lose market share and their stakeholders would be harmed. This obviously shouldn't require restitution.
Also, it's very hard to measure both positive and negative externalities.
I couldn’t agree more that it is difficult to measure externalities. A good place to start might be to get a quote for the cost of undoing the harm - e.g. I’ve heard as low as $93 a ton to remove carbon dioxide from the atmosphere. Seems like a reasonable starting point for discussion.
By the way I don’t think making a better widget qualifies as a negative externality.
I also think it's a bit simplistic: what if we find that the carbon energy sector is not capturing all the value of what it provides and has positive externalities that outweigh the negatives at current levels?
What do you do about systems with non-linear effects like the climate?
I think we shouldn't try and seek a general operating principle from a known hard problem that we are failing to address and is pretty different from others we face.
We should have a carbon tax, because it is a useful tool in fighting this battle, not because it is the right tool for every issue.
Seriously, we have all the tech to radically reduce emissions starting now. But it costs businesses money to do it, and the future benefit is distributed across all humanity, so nobody does it voluntarily. We need governments to agree to force everyone to do something that benefits society, which stands in stark contrast to market capitalism.
Putting a price tag on externalities is about asserting either a state wide, or even world wide ownership on some resource -- whether it be fish stocks, clean air, electromagnetic spectra, etc, etc, etc. This is completely different than a collective/shared ownership by a group of people.
Such an idea does not detract in any way from market capitalism. In fact, giving these common resources an owner who can establish a price for their use is exactly what capitalism is all about. We could even go so far as to enact economic fascism by giving ownership of these resources to "elite" companies who will be able to manage them most efficiently (also read as, "giving ownership of these resources to our friends who will be able to maintain their vast wealth and power eternally"). I only mention it since fascism is about as far from communism as you can get (unless, as is often done, you wrap around on the other side of the spectrum ;-) ).
The US has a particular view that government ownership should be kept at a minimum. This idea suffers from the problem of either tragedy of the commons (for unregulated common resources and externalities), or with monopolistic ownership of key resources by certain companies (the latter tending towards an economic fascist ideal). I think it's this idea that somebody has to own this stuff and the government is probably the best somebody to own it that's very difficult to swallow for American ideology. But that doesn't mean it can't change.
Just look at the European carbon tax (ETS); it would have been effective if reasonably priced (50-100 EUR/tonne range), but industry successfully worked to keep the price per tonne at between 1/5th and 1/20th of what would have spurred actual emissions reduction measures, thus it has been toothless. Greenwashing is most all what remains.
Draw a control volume around your business or product. If, during the creation, use, or disposal of your product or business, mass or energy crosses this boundary, you should be required to provide for any negative externalities caused by this material or energy.
Of course, as usual with this approach, the magic is all in the drawing of the boundary, but hear me out.
Under this framework, it may be a bit easier to see clearly what externalities we might wish to price. I sincerely believe that if we now shrink from this present task of properly pricing and managing these costs, human society will perish from this earth.