It is likely there are portions of the population, who have a better response to a placebo than to the actual drug - but! - the reverse is also a likely scenario. I.e. there are people who don't respond to a placebo and show a strong therapeutic response to an actual drug.
Hence, if one is capable, one should always have an active attitude to ones treatment - what works for someone else, may not work for you, and vice versa.
I hope someone can dig out the reference to this... I read this from a reputable source, but damn if I can remember from where anymore.
Then maybe we don't need drugs approved?
The FDA knows how much more complex neuroscience is to develop drugs for and has chosen the latter option as an ethical necessity.
It will be true some of the time, but there's lots of room for a drug to do more harm than good in that situation.
Yes, you only need 2 positive phase 3 trials to get your drug approved. Yes, you could have done 10 others and had them fail. Yes, the FDA already knows this.
The FDA is willing to approve drugs for depression with much weaker data than say, cancer, because if they held them to the same standard, no drugs would be approved at all.