My favorite "Incentives matter" story is FedEx - they were having a hell of a time getting drivers to get packages shipped on time. They tried all sorts of things - threatening, praising, performance reviews, training, etc.
None of it worked.
Then they changed their pay from "per hour" to "per shift" - you work a shift, you get paid a certain amount. Go home when you complete your shift, regardless of how long it takes you.
Right away, their on time rate went massively up - in fact, a lot of shifts started being completed early at that point.
Unfortunately for me, I wasn't close friends with the manager of the store. He gave all the shortest runs to all his mates, making it nigh on impossible to get a bonus unless you suffered his patronage.
So what happened next? Did FedEx management cut pay since the job was easier than they previously thought?
Nope. Not once, ever.
But then again, I don't use FedEx Home Delivery, as they are not actually FedEx. (FedEx contracts that out to random local trucking companies. The express deliveries are the ones they handle themselves, and fortunately everything I get via Amazon Prime is either UPS or FedEx Express.)
They do indeed: http://www.braunconsulting.com/bcg/newsletters/winter2004/wi...
(When I was a contractor for Bank of America, I got the same Bank of America business cards that everyone else did. Contracting does necessarily mean "setup this one webserver" or "deliver these 83 random boxes today"; it can also be a full-time thing.)
I assume they don't mind the reputation damage because the price is what matters in the "home delivery" business. They care that their $100 overnight letters get delivered on time; your 60 pound box of laundry detergent doesn't mean much to them.
You would think that with the explosion of personal shipping in the last fifteen years caused by the Internet, that these companies would have figured out residential deliveries by now but, if anything, it's become worse.
A HTC Wildfire is around $50 with subscription, and once all couriers have them we intend to extend the system as much as we can. Lots of cute stuff should be possible with a combination of camera/barcode reader/gps/internet device.
I try to find some consolation in believing that me reporting them will have some effect.
There's a king who wants have very rich and flavorful soup, so he tells his chef that, for every drop of grease floating in his bowl, he will pay a coin. The greedy chef wants to maximize his pay, so he dumps a lot of oil into the soup. Of course, this results in a single oil slick across the entire top of the bowl, so the king pays him only a single coin.
(A) Articulating exactly what you want
(B) Measuring that accurately
(C) Keeping out things you don't want
None of these are easy problems to solve. And they are generally ignored because most people don't realize they are problems at all.Every so often someone would call up and ask about some odd item on their bill, and it would end up being some bullshit charge for something they didn't get, or a carefully selected charge that was similar to, but not really, they service that was actually provided.
But since most of the time the costs were covered by some other party most people didn't bother inspecting their bills or statements, or bother looking closely at what was charged.
2) Price it at $5,000. No one would actually pay that price of course.
3) Let people who have Medicare get them. Send the bill to Medicare, which is obligated to pay because it's a covered medical appliance.
My second, immediately following thought, was "Pay them to not kill passengers."
That's progress - how to get simple incentives right is a lot more obvious now to economically literate folk than it was back then.
In the 1940’s, the paleontologist von Koenigswald was searching for early human remains on Java and decided to enlist the help of the locals in his search by offering them “ten cents for every piece of hominid bone they could come up with.” Unfortunately for von Koenigswald (and for his findings), he discovered too late that the locals “had been enthusiastically smashing large pieces into small ones to maximize their income.”
From http://freakonomics.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/10/20/when-youre-...
(The story is from the book A Short History of Nearly Everything, which is one of the best books I've ever read. The amazing thing about the book is that it is in fact a short history of nearly everything.)
Combine the difficulty of getting incentives right with the inherent problems of Government and a dangerous mix results. For example, every time a subsidy is created, a special-interest group sprouts up dedicated to preserving the subsidy in perpetuity, long after it has outlived its utility.