News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask YC: What's the best advice you ever got? by Retric on Thursday May 08, 2008 @12:29PM (#184697)
just because people don't agree on what moral knowledge is true does not make the term meaningless

Words or phrases only have meaning when there is a shared understanding of what they mean. GLARPF people who JAVARA understand this SLFARL VERORLRA when they SFLLKKLSA. You can't agree to that statement because it has no meaning but at the same time you can't disagree with it. If you define love as the sky and then say "the sky is love" there is no meaning to those words. Basically defining terms is semantically identical to gibberish. IMO, this is why people gave up on philosophy as a science.

PS: I don’t disagree with your original statement because it lacked meaning.

Re:Ask YC: What's the best advice you ever got? by xlnt on Thursday May 08, 2008 @12:38PM (#184708)
There is shared understanding of what 'morality' means. There is also disagreement. The same can be said of a wide variety of other words, such as 'christianity', 'freedom', or 'liberal'. None of these words are meaningless or useless in conversation despite the existence of some disagreement about their meanings.