Ask HN:My former co-founder is threatening to sue me
I am from a third world country and my fomer co-founder is a u.s citizen.
We have been working since last 3 years on a ad network start-up which closed earlier this year.
I started a part-time project and i need some money to sustain myself so i decided to ask for 500 USD for 6 months and also 2 - 4 hrs commitment everyday from my former co-founder the project kicked off really well and we generated about 6K income in 1 week after the expenses our total profit was about 4K.
My co-founder paid for 2 months thats 500x2 after that the venture was profitable so he never paid and he didnt commit any time in 6 months he only spend 10-15 days avg 1-2 hrs on advicing and i myself spend 18 hrs a day in coding and business development.
After repeatly warning him i dedicided yesterday asked to not to do any futher business with him and pay him for the expenses and he got mad hearing this he threatened to sue in U.S court and file a grandtheft against me he says i will never be able to step in US or do business with a US company if i dont give him 2000 USD right now plus 50% of the company.
I feel cheated to work with someone who cannot commit time and effort as much i do in the venture.
All agreements we had were via chat and voice and not in legal sheet.
The company is a not us company but must of our customers are from u.s.
Please advice
Thank you !
If this company made 4000 US$ in a week (as you say), it is worth a lot of money and you will need to negotiate with him. Offering to pay him 1000$ for his part (ie. "his expenses") is ridiculously low.
I would just incorporate on your own, in India. Run your business as if he didn't exist. He won't do anything.
NEVER assume someone won't sue you. In our case, the agreement in question was signed by one partner under the representation of a completely separate corporation, without the knowledge of any of the other shareholders. It doesn't get any more far fetched than that. If we don't defend ourselves, the judgement is awarded by default and the plaintiff gains all kinds of ability to levy liens, garnish wages, and a host of other bullshit. Basically, it's like running a marathon with a ball and chain strapped to both legs. It's the last thing you need as a startup. Find a way to reach an agreement and get past it.
But apparently if you have been paid for a job you agreed to do then that's considered a contract even if no documents were signed. If there are any lawyers out there please correct me.
People often try to take credit for your success, but back away from your failures. Since OP presumably has a $1 million dollar idea, he could get a MUCH better valuation - give away 20% for $200k.
It's not clear but it's not nothing either.
I'm not a lawyer, but I did study a little business law, especially contracts. Contrary to common belief, you don't need something in writing for an agreement to be considered a contract. See, for instance:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Implied-in-fact_contract
The transfer of the $1000 is pretty clear evidence of an agreement. Then there's records of the regular calls/chats. The partner, while maybe a jerk, has some claims of ownership here. (Also, I think he's probably less of a malicious jerk and more likely he's feeling hurt/threatened/betrayed - the threats to sue were in response to being told he's being kicked out of a business he presumably thinks he owns half of, took a risk on with his cash, and has put in some hours of his life)
Conversely, it's impossible for a Indian citizen to own individual ownership in a US company (unless it's through a company JV type arrangement, or he has a legal visa to work in the US - this is the founders dilemma that often plagues startups)
Additionally, it's near impossible to sue a foreign corporation without a US presence.
This whole situation is sticky, and the US "investor" has little leverage. One would think that if he really wanted to take 50% ownership of the company, he would have thought through all these issues - but he didn't.
Since he was the one that threatened to sue, you have to play hardball - you have to take that threat seriously, even though it might not be credible.
Rohan: Remember that any admission that equity should be given can later be used in court (if somehow, someway it ends up in a court case...but always prepare for the D-Day case)
Remember: you own the code, the servers, and the bank accounts. You control all the leverage. What has been said is done for now, but if I were you I would calculate all the hours you put into the project, and show that the $500 doesn't take you very fair.
Additionally, someone that "wants 50% of the profits for the next 2 months". Seriously, what kind of business arrangement is that?
As I said in another response, remember that he's also responsible for 50% of the costs. As managing partner, you can take on additional equity, and he'd have to match that, or risk being diluted.
Actually, it's easy for an Indian to have an ownership interest in a US company.
The founders problem is that US immigration law doesn't have a special case for self-employment and SE is what a startup looks like.
Presumably, he can use the business model knowledge to get a new domain, start a real company, and redo the same business model on his own.
It sounds like the US guy is really going to push him around. Sue him? How is he going to serve the papers in India? With no contract? Really don't think lawyer would take that case.
If it comes down to a bunch of IM's sent, well then it'll be case of "was this an equity investment, or was it a loan". If the OP paid him back, a strong argument could be made that it was a loan.
You said that you made 6k in one week; after saying that you've been working on this start up for 3 years. Is the $4,000 the entire profit this company made over the course of those 3 years? Based on these inconsistencies, I'm finding it hard to follow your story.
To start; IANAL so YMMV.
It sounds to me like you went in with different mentalities. You were a founder; he was an investor. I realize that from your perspective, "he didn't put as much time in" as you did; however, you agreed to give him some share of the company for his monetary investment. That said, it sounds like the valuation agreed to was $6,000 when he invested and that by contributing $3,000, he would own 50% of the company.
However, if he only invested $1,000, then he actually bought only 1/6th of the company, not 1/2. My calculations say you owe him approximately $1,680 which includes returning his initial investment and the profits from a 17% share of the company (which he really does own whether you like it or not).
All that said, if he can document actual material contributions to your products, he quite likely has a legitimate claim for a higher share.
The lesson here is NEVER do business in any form of partnership without a written agreement as to the ownership levels, roles, and responsibilities of each partner.
Chat/email/voice are more than sufficient to establish a contract in the US legal system. Read the introductory "elements of a contract" section from here: http://www.expertlaw.com/library/business/contract_law.html
What you can do and what you should do are different things. If he's not keeping up his end of the contract, then sue him in the country the company is registered in. Don't give him time or the benefit of jurisdiction in any legal action. If you just don't like the guy, he likely still owns part of the business.
IANAL, but chat or email probably count as "in writing."
It does sound like bluster. It's certainly not grand theft (which would be a criminal matter), it's a contractual dispute. When people start throwing around legal terms they don't understand I always suspect that they either aren't serious, or that they know so little that their intent is irrelevant as it's likely to change when they learn the reality of the situation, the likely costs and so on.
My guess is that if you made him an offer - possibly just 50% of profit to date - he'd accept and go, but what you need to make sure is that any deal you do with him makes clear that the payment is made in full and final settlement of the matter.
In the UK full and final settlement is a specific legal term (I'm guessing that there is a US equivalent) basically meaning that the matter is settled and the other party can't then return at a later date with a further claim. This should be stated clearly in the accompanying letter (make sure the letter and payment are signed for and you record all details) and also make it clear that by cashing the cheque he waives any right to further payment or claim against you or the company in relation to any business dealings you have had.
But the point others have made is valid - just because it's not worth him suing now don't assume it won't be worth it in the future.
By the way: when replying, use the 'reply' link.
(I don't know the answers to those questions)
Additionally, an American investor can't be an individual investor in an Indian corporation.
If they really wanted to be on the "up-and-up", the American investor would have set up an American company, with the Indian company as a 50% investor. Then, the Indian company would sign a legal document assigning all copyrights to the American company.
Since nothing was on the up-and-up, and nothing was even signed (I hate email/telephone contracts), the American investor has very little leverage. Since he's threatening to sue, I would exploit it.
Could the "new venture" be viewed by a U.S. court as a continuation of the old venture? Could the acceptance of the $1000 salary in the first two months be construed as a contract of some sort? Also, the OP says in a comment that he requested that a US corporation be formed, so there are probably emails to that effect. Would such a request be considered to mean there was a partnership in place already?
Again, I agree with other commenters, there will not be a lawsuit over $2000. But the 50% of the company could be enough incentive if you were successful enough, so the OP might want to get solid on where he stands. It sounds to me that there's a bit of a backstory, maybe enough to make a court look twice.
Now, you feel like he's not worth what he's getting, and this happens. Actually, one of the most common reasons partnerships break down is because of perception of the other guy's work rate.
I'd look to negotiate a buyout for him. He does own some of the company. On your side of the story, it looks horribly unjust. But you know, there's his side of the story where he spends time thinking about the company, consulting with you, risks his money, etc. He's probably feeling like you're trying to screw him and that you're being terribly unfair as well.
Try to negotiate a buyout that includes him relinquishing all ownership of the company. He did put time and money into this and backed you with no guarantee of return - he's entitled to something. The court thing is a non-issue at this stage unless he's really vindictive, but it'll be like an ax hanging over your head forever if your project is successful, or you want to hire, or raise money, or anything else. Try to buy him out and go on your own way. When you negotiate, don't tell him how unfair it is, etc, etc. This just ticks people off without accomplishing anything. Just focus on how you don't think this is a good partnership any more, and you're sorry it didn't work out, and after thinking about it you'd like to buy him out, and then make a low offer and come up a bit.
But certainly the other founder is entitled to a lot more than a thousand dollars here (though there's some vagueness in the description). A good negotiating position might be to tell him he can have half the company or the $2000, and plan to get bid up on the $2000 side somewhat.
Everyone keeps bringing up US laws with regards to ownership, but remember that this is an INDIAN company, where different rules apply.
It would take a brave soul indeed to get involved in that from abroad with relatively little at stake.
If you are running the business and he is doing no work on it right now, it is reasonable for you to pay yourself a respectable salary before sending any profits back. Plenty of companies don't pay dividends. But unless you are eager to shoot yourself in the foot you need to send him an email apologizing for your behavior and putting things right.
And I would love to hear from those of you downmodding my comments on why exactly you think this guy should get a free ride on the do-unto-others principle. And please post under your real accounts so others have fair warning when they make agreements with you.
Also, how the hell is he screwing his countrymen, as you claim? Are you saying that because someone got screwed by someone in country X, noone will want to do business with other people from country X anymore? That makes no sense.
That's the reason for the threat. He has no other way.
When things turn nasty you end up with a zero sum game at best, and quite often you end up lose-lose. You CAN make it win-win again, you just need to detach your emotions and do what's best for you both.
You shared risks and responsibilities of the venture along with the money. Keeping aside the friction with the co-founder, you deserve 50% of the company.
> "My co-founder paid for 2 months"
> "10-15 days avg 1-2 hrs on advicing"
Not a lawyer, but based on the post I would suspect that there is a straight forward argument under common law that the ex-cofounder was in breech of contract.
Sounds like the whole thing is pretty much screwed.
> The company is a not us company but must of our customers are from u.s.
Who owns the company?
If you feel you owe him more, give him what you think he is worth to buy him out. If you think you owe him nothing, then cut off communication from him.
He has to sue you in your country of residence so until you start hearing from local courts, I wouldn't worry.
2months X 4 weeks X 4K per week = 32K. Minus operating expenses for 2 months (Let's just use 500 per month here) = 31K Minus taxes (assuming 25%) = 23.25K
$11625 to have a clean corp that grosses 208K a year. Sounds like a no brainer for me... Pay him off, make him sign a final and complete settlement that previous poster suggested.
BTW, don't let the word "grand" theft scare you. Any theft exceeding $400 is called "grand".
Your best option, state you are walking away form venture and that if he wants the 50% you owned to pay up..
Now, when you create the new one..get a lawyer involved and have things in writing.