News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A new wave of grain by agsdfgsd on Thursday November 15, 2018 @06:03PM (#18464318)
What is the purpose exactly? Everything I can find about it is just hand wavey "its good for the environment because reasons".
Re:A new wave of grain by zeckalpha on Thursday November 15, 2018 @06:16PM (#18464405)
No need to till, better drought tolerance.
Re:A new wave of grain by agsdfgsd on Thursday November 15, 2018 @06:20PM (#18464438)
There's no need to till with any other grain either, the majority of grain is farmed no-till already. Is there any actual evidence of better drought tolerance, or is that just assumed based on the misconception that perennials are more drought tolerant than annuals?
Re:A new wave of grain by cwkoss on Friday November 16, 2018 @02:01PM (#18471063)
Growing grains requires:

Prep soil -> Plant -> Wait -> Harvest

Perennial grains would allow you to do the prep and plant once, and then repeat the last two steps multiple times. Prep, Planting, and Harvest are all similar orders of magnitude of labor, so if you can get ~ 5 years from a single planting, you could work an area of land with less than half the total labor.

Less soil prep and planting (with heavy machinery) means less soil erosion, less microbiome destruction, healthier soil.

Re:A new wave of grain by agsdfgsd on Saturday November 17, 2018 @11:15AM (#18476063)
>Prep soil

That's not required at all. Most grain is grown no-till, you seed directly through the residue of the previous crop. This is the typical problem, people researching solutions to problems that don't actually exist. Why are agricultural researchers completely unfamiliar with basic farming practices?

>you could work an area of land with less than half the total labor.

And get less food from it because the grain has such a low yield. You're burning fewer gallons of diesel per calorie of food produced to grow normal wheat than any of the perennial grains they have come up with so far.

>Less soil prep and planting (with heavy machinery) means less soil erosion, less microbiome destruction, healthier soil

But we solved that problem decades ago, solving it again but worse isn't very useful.

Re:A new wave of grain by cwkoss on Saturday November 17, 2018 @04:09PM (#18477420)
It seems like you've already made up your mind, so not sure why I'm bothering, but...

>Most grain is grown no-till

I don't think this is accurate for wheat.

> food produced to grow normal wheat than any of the perennial grains they have come up with so far

A brand new innovation is less efficient that an existing tech that has existed for centuries? Crazy.

> But we solved that problem decades ago

We've solved soil destruction? What?