News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Here is a Basic Private Messaging Tool for news.yc Users by BrandonM on Tuesday May 01, 2007 @02:27PM (#18462)
This seems like an interesting way to tack on community functions to any web site on the Internet. The hard part is to get users to trust you with their username and password, but perhaps the spread of OpenIDs could help that situation for you.

Have you given any thought to turning this idea into something more? The withmsg.com domain name should work great for any site.

Re:Here is a Basic Private Messaging Tool for news.yc Users by whacked_new on Tuesday May 01, 2007 @08:43PM (#18534)
I thought about the "more" part a little, just a little; there are some important problems to think through before carrying this further. First of all, it only provides a substitute functionality; if news.yc gets PM then this is totally unnecessary. For more features, there are more ambitious projects like medium (I'm not sure if they're in the same category).

Second, being an unofficial product degrades credibility by a lot; there's no reason why a user would expect to find messages for them on an external server. I imagine this as a disposable tool, like mailinator, in case some people want to trade emails or other non-public data without having to write here or disclose anything personal. Post and delete. For this specific purpose I do think its useful, but how much further beyond the audience especially concerned about privacy, I don't know.

Third, loading an external page in a frame can confuse and annoy users, so I think it's not a good practice. news.yc users might tolerate this kind of hack because they know what's behind it, but I can't say for sure.

Of course, if you have other thoughts/suggestions, do let me know, publicly or privately :)

Re:Here is a Basic Private Messaging Tool for news.yc Users by edgeztv on Tuesday May 01, 2007 @02:53PM (#18465)
I had the same idea a while back :)