Re:Is The Chinese Supercomputer Our Sputnik?
by jlouis on Friday October 29, 2010 @07:24AM
(#1846887)
The article is wrong on " The fastest supercomputer has, since 1994, resided in the United States at the Oak Ridge National Laboratory, where it is used for scientific computing, among other purposes."
I present to the thee, the Japanese Earth Simulator:
Re:Is The Chinese Supercomputer Our Sputnik?
by ihumanable on Friday October 29, 2010 @10:01AM
(#1847325)
I think the article is making the argument that the goal of having the fastest X or the biggest X or being the first to X is not the point. Supercomputers have real value, in the sense that they are used to solve real problems that can't be solved otherwise. The bigger point seems to be that the benefit in getting to X is that you normally create a lot of technology that ends up being beneficial to the economy in general.
Having an uninterruptable communication network led to the internet. Being able to deploy ICBMs across the nation led to the Highway System. Going to space created a ton of new materials and manufacturing systems that have created products that couldn't have existed before.
Having the fastest supercomputer is the trees, the forest is the wealth of technology and industries born out of that race.
Re:Is The Chinese Supercomputer Our Sputnik?
by dotBen on Friday October 29, 2010 @04:06PM
(#1848799)
Supercomputers have real value, in the sense that they are used to solve real problems that can't be solved otherwise
Sure, and this answers the question "why have super-computers", indeed, the US has several.
I'm not just sure if any of the reasons you specify, all valid, suddenly become invalid when there is simply a delta between the power of US vs China systems.
Re:Is The Chinese Supercomputer Our Sputnik?
by dmlorenzetti on Friday October 29, 2010 @09:59AM
(#1847317)
One could flip that question around and ask: Why does China need the fastest machine? The significance of the story isn't that America no longer ranks first.
I believe that in general, the really fast machines serve one of two purposes-- simulating nukes (for example, to test new designs), and simulating global environment (for example, to improve climate predictions).
Re:Is The Chinese Supercomputer Our Sputnik?
by nkassis on Friday October 29, 2010 @01:21AM
(#1846258)
There was an article posted here on HN not too long ago about Japan's 5th generation computer project. It was more about what killed logic programming but this China+supercomputing thing reminds me of this a little.
Re:Is The Chinese Supercomputer Our Sputnik?
by thelema314 on Friday October 29, 2010 @02:46AM
(#1846419)
The Chinese CPU is junk, and the chinese supercomputer is built out of US parts - I wouldn't be too apocalyptic about technological superiority for some years yet.
Re:Is The Chinese Supercomputer Our Sputnik?
by heresy on Friday October 29, 2010 @07:46AM
(#1846932)
Until the interconnect is a commodity, and at any point the advances they've made there can be as easily utilized in building new US supercomputers.
I don't really see the point of this chest thumping, whoever does it, it just seems like so much posturing. It's fast. Great, but get back to actual science please.
Re:Is The Chinese Supercomputer Our Sputnik?
by Tichy on Friday October 29, 2010 @04:46AM
(#1846628)
"Supercomputing is at the basis of many important scientific and commercial enterprises in the United States, and it is very important that we not relinquish our lead in this area."
Re:Is The Chinese Supercomputer Our Sputnik?
by possibilistic on Saturday October 30, 2010 @12:04AM
(#1850058)
I'm studying to become an interdiciplinary computational biochemist, so perhaps I can lend some perspective.
Supercomputers are increasingly used in the sciences to scale down the search space of massively complicated problems such as protein folding, molecular docking, and chemical synthesis. In several instances they lead us to novel, non-intuitive results, sometimes as small as finding a functional group prefering a gauched vs anti conformation that changes a particular interaction completely. With drug design specifically, we can cut down the chemical search space necessary to find inhibitor molecules and search for potential problematic harmful interactions before ever running in vitro assays.
Science today is more serendipity and hard work than acts of sheer brilliance. Having high-throughput tools that save us from looking too hard give us more time to think and more quickly update our models.
Supercomputing will lead us to smarter medicine, cures for cancer, better materials, and a more energy-efficient planet. Computer science is a major cornerstone of today's scientific endeavors, and we increasingly need to encourage interest and investment in this field.
Re:Is The Chinese Supercomputer Our Sputnik?
by adaml_623 on Friday October 29, 2010 @05:38AM
(#1846724)
Such a sad US vs THEM post.
Americans are just going to have to accept that the playing field is becoming more level and eventually a country with 1 Billion people is going to be more productive than a country with 300 Million people. It's just arithmetic.
And it's not the end of the world. It's ok to just live in a country and have a cool life.
Re:Is The Chinese Supercomputer Our Sputnik?
by garply on Friday October 29, 2010 @07:02AM
(#1846847)
That's good to point out, but China is consciously adopting a Western legal and economic system (with some notable modifications) on which to run its society. If they do it successfully, the larger amount of people should give the country a greater amount of productivity than the US.
Re:Is The Chinese Supercomputer Our Sputnik?
by gaius on Friday October 29, 2010 @07:18AM
(#1846874)
That's a very fine balancing act. Everything is magnified. What if 10% unemployment in the US economy at an equivalent tech level translates to 60% in China? Perhaps the Chinese will choose to keep productivity at a controlled level to prevent social unrest.
Re:Is The Chinese Supercomputer Our Sputnik?
by adaml_623 on Friday October 29, 2010 @10:08AM
(#1847344)
What no that's a crazy comment. Expand on your one line with your examples.
History is full of examples of countries with big populations doing big things. And countries with tiny populations achieving less. Of course the number of people makes a difference.
Re:Is The Chinese Supercomputer Our Sputnik?
by gaius on Friday October 29, 2010 @12:02PM
(#1847739)
Well on the subject of China let's start with Ghengis Khan conquering not only China but a vast empire... Or Athens, or Rome (these pre-date Greece and Italy existing as countries)... Or England, Holland and Portugal building vast trading empires and driving the Renaissance and the Industrial Revolution.
I present to the thee, the Japanese Earth Simulator:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Earth_Simulator
Having an uninterruptable communication network led to the internet. Being able to deploy ICBMs across the nation led to the Highway System. Going to space created a ton of new materials and manufacturing systems that have created products that couldn't have existed before.
Having the fastest supercomputer is the trees, the forest is the wealth of technology and industries born out of that race.
Sure, and this answers the question "why have super-computers", indeed, the US has several.
I'm not just sure if any of the reasons you specify, all valid, suddenly become invalid when there is simply a delta between the power of US vs China systems.
I believe that in general, the really fast machines serve one of two purposes-- simulating nukes (for example, to test new designs), and simulating global environment (for example, to improve climate predictions).
Here's the article: http://vanemden.wordpress.com/2010/08/21/who-killed-prolog/
EDIT: Wikipedia page about the project: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fifth_generation_computer
I don't really see the point of this chest thumping, whoever does it, it just seems like so much posturing. It's fast. Great, but get back to actual science please.
Details, please. Otherwise it is just blubbering.
Supercomputers are increasingly used in the sciences to scale down the search space of massively complicated problems such as protein folding, molecular docking, and chemical synthesis. In several instances they lead us to novel, non-intuitive results, sometimes as small as finding a functional group prefering a gauched vs anti conformation that changes a particular interaction completely. With drug design specifically, we can cut down the chemical search space necessary to find inhibitor molecules and search for potential problematic harmful interactions before ever running in vitro assays.
Science today is more serendipity and hard work than acts of sheer brilliance. Having high-throughput tools that save us from looking too hard give us more time to think and more quickly update our models.
Supercomputing will lead us to smarter medicine, cures for cancer, better materials, and a more energy-efficient planet. Computer science is a major cornerstone of today's scientific endeavors, and we increasingly need to encourage interest and investment in this field.
Americans are just going to have to accept that the playing field is becoming more level and eventually a country with 1 Billion people is going to be more productive than a country with 300 Million people. It's just arithmetic.
And it's not the end of the world. It's ok to just live in a country and have a cool life.
History is full of examples of countries with big populations doing big things. And countries with tiny populations achieving less. Of course the number of people makes a difference.
Numbers are nothing. Culture is fate.