Re:Aequitas – An open source bias audit toolkit for machine ...
by opwieurposiu on Friday November 16, 2018 @11:58AM
(#18469938)
I find the premise that different groups should expect the same percentage of interventions highly suspect. Imagine we have a program that distributes seeing eye dogs. This toolkit would discover that sighted persons have a 0% chance of getting a dog, while blind persons have a 50% chance. Oh the injustice!
Re:Aequitas – An open source bias audit toolkit for machine ...
by to_bpr on Friday November 16, 2018 @10:25AM
(#18469301)
If the goal is equity of outcome above-all-else, ignoring for any differences derived from the data, then why are we bothered investing so much time, money and effort into this area?
It's not just about letting the data speak. The data is gathered by someone, containing historical bias we might nowadays disagree with, models are chosen by people, using parameters set by people, using evaluations set by people. It's about making sure models are both predictive, usable, and fair.
This article: https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-018-05469-3 also highlights the issues pretty well IMO.
It's not just about letting the data speak. The data is gathered by someone, containing historical bias we might nowadays disagree with, models are chosen by people, using parameters set by people, using evaluations set by people. It's about making sure models are both predictive, usable, and fair.