News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What the Boston School Bus Schedule Can Teach Us about AI by joe_the_user on Wednesday November 14, 2018 @04:01PM (#18453907)
Sure, an inclusive headline is "What the Boston School Bus Schedule Can Teach us About letting algorithms decide". Because AI or upper division math, the decision was consigned to a process that is opaque to the average parent. And the opaqueness more or less conceals basic tradeoffs.

The school has figured out that starting HS late-ish and letting all student out before dark provides the best situation for students.

But if all school levels start at the same time, the district has would have to have a bunch of school buses and drivers that wouldn't be used other times.

To avoid all this "waste", the district has to decide which schools to shove into some other, worse schedule. They thus came up with a algorithm to minimize the amount of bad-scheduling but which maintains the existence of bad-schedules. And when it sent an entirely different group than before into the bad-scheduled situation, naturally that group complained - it didn't help these were wealthier, whiter groups with influence.

Sure, you thus have more affluent people saying they didn't want to be the one sacrificed here. But you also ask, why sacrifice anyone? Why not bite the bullet and have a good, standard schedule for all schools? You'd offending the modern god of efficiency but you'd actually be aiming for a greater good.

The article talks about Trolley Car Problems a bit and how people relate to algorithms "solving" these. The thing is instead of saying "that there are sacrifices is given, now we must decide who", which guarantees divisiveness, one could say "let us make choices as a society which mean that no person a priori need be sacrificed."

Re:What the Boston School Bus Schedule Can Teach Us about AI by pg_bot on Wednesday November 14, 2018 @04:32PM (#18454187)
"that there are sacrifices is given, now we must decide who", which guarantees divisiveness, one could say "let us make choices as a society which mean that no person a priori need be sacrificed."

Your first quote describes reality, your second is nonsense. If there were an outcome where everyone's needs are met and nothing need be sacrificed, there would be no opposition to the changes. Every decision comes at a cost, we don't have unlimited resources so we should reach for tools that attempt to maximize what we are willing to spend. If you believe that no one needs to sacrifice in order to solve society's problems, you are living in a fantasy.

Re:What the Boston School Bus Schedule Can Teach Us about AI by joe_the_user on Wednesday November 14, 2018 @04:49PM (#18454361)
Your first quote describes reality, your second is nonsense. If there were an outcome where everyone's needs are met and nothing need be sacrificed, there would be no opposition to the changes.

Basic income is system that would approximately guarantee all people's basic needs are met yet there is certainly opposition to it.

Re:What the Boston School Bus Schedule Can Teach Us about AI by killjoywashere on Wednesday November 14, 2018 @05:10PM (#18454589)
Your proposals sound to me like someone going to a casino with a surefire winning strategy assuming they have more money than the house.

Please explain (or cite a source that does) how you roll out a basic income in a way that doesn't create new schemes that leave more money on the table to be hoovered up by the oligarchic corporations. I strongly biased to believe that if you add resources arbitrarily to a human society, then a segment of the population will, will, find a way to capture them.

Re:What the Boston School Bus Schedule Can Teach Us about AI by joe_the_user on Wednesday November 14, 2018 @06:03PM (#18455060)
I am not even a proponent of basic income.

The point is that in policy today, "everyone's needs will be met" isn't an automatically a winning argument.

Re:What the Boston School Bus Schedule Can Teach Us about AI by jacobush on Thursday November 15, 2018 @03:09AM (#18457669)
Off topic, but as long as I trust the state, I trust basic income.

I put different amount of faith in different states, but not very much in any state. Not in the long run. The problem is, the state is going to dictate more and more conditions for receiving that income. Couple it with oligarchic interests and no good can come of it.

Problem is, I don't see much good coming from our current systems either, subverted as we speak.