News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Compelled Decryption and the Privilege Against Self-Incri... by bensonn on Wednesday November 14, 2018 @03:34PM (#18453615)
These arguments almost always seem like encryption is about access to information but isn't encryption about understanding information? If they are asking for a key to decrypt then they already have access to the data. If you write a note nobody will ever have access to- say you slipped it onto Voyager 1, there would be no point in encrypting it. Encryption is to protect against (possibly) accessible data.

Old-school though experiment- I encrypt all my paper notes using a simple substitution cipher. They seize my notes and have full physical access to them. If they don't understand my notes can I be forced to explain my cipher?

If I comply and the unscrambled contents are "RedFalcon has delivered the ApplePie to the EndOfTheRainbow". This is basically another substitution cipher. Can I be forced to explain this under threat of jail if I don't explain it in a way they accept?

I realize modern encryption is way beyond this, and way beyond my understanding. Has the basic principle of access vs understanding changed?

Re:Compelled Decryption and the Privilege Against Self-Incri... by fandango on Thursday November 15, 2018 @08:46AM (#18459150)
Exactly. It'd like to make this analogy myself: Forcing somebody to decrypt a drive is like forcing somebody to keep rearranging a bunch of papers/notes (he or she supposedly produced) until a punishable offence is noticed. Are you not able to compose a satisfactory result? It's jail for you because you are hiding something.