News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What the Boston School Bus Schedule Can Teach Us about AI by existencebox on Wednesday November 14, 2018 @01:56PM (#18452685)
Am I the only one who reads this and gets the takeaway of: "Journalist realizes he was on the wrong side of defending a special interest group against the greater good via lack of due diligence, tries to backpedal and paint himself in a positive light via 'learnings'"

I think I'd be less cynical if they had done less to bury the lede deep in the midst of the article, and not once mention "due diligence," let alone as the crux or conclusion that I took as the real Root Cause here.

To me this isn't a story about AI. This is "just another" story of how readily public decision making can be swayed by biased special interests and an uninformed media/electorate.

The author should be praised for revisiting the topic, being upfront about their change in stance and trying to close the loop on it; but I think I am seeing the problem space from a very different angle than they are.

Re:What the Boston School Bus Schedule Can Teach Us about AI by DevX101 on Wednesday November 14, 2018 @02:19PM (#18452938)
>Journalist realizes he was on the wrong side of defending a special interest group

Author of the article is Joi Ito, director of the MIT Media Lab. I wish he had spoken to the original creators of the algorithm (down the street) before co-authoring the article.

But I give him credit for this kind-of a mea culpa w/ additional context.

Re:What the Boston School Bus Schedule Can Teach Us about AI by stevenwoo on Wednesday November 14, 2018 @03:37PM (#18453654)
Yes, and I only read the first two pages because it made me a little ill how shabbily they came to their initial conclusion - anyone with an inkling of knowledge of the history of the USA and school bussing would have approached this more carefully.
Re:What the Boston School Bus Schedule Can Teach Us about AI by jackconnor on Wednesday November 14, 2018 @02:43PM (#18453162)
You nailed it, though I'm happy he wrote the piece at all despite it being a secret "mea culpa" piece.
Re:What the Boston School Bus Schedule Can Teach Us about AI by the_crocodile on Wednesday November 14, 2018 @08:44PM (#18456187)
Agree. This brings increased attention and news to an issue that would have been forgotten. It speaks to Joi's integrity that he wanted to correct his mistake publicly.
Re:What the Boston School Bus Schedule Can Teach Us about AI by frandroid on Wednesday November 14, 2018 @06:32PM (#18455298)
What's secret about this?
Re:What the Boston School Bus Schedule Can Teach Us about AI by lbarrow on Wednesday November 14, 2018 @02:25PM (#18453006)
Yea, it really seems like the author originally just flipped out at the word "algorithm" and is now backpeddling after realizing he was pretty uniformed.
Re:What the Boston School Bus Schedule Can Teach Us about AI by SilasX on Wednesday November 14, 2018 @02:45PM (#18453180)
I'm having trouble untangling the story from reading it. Who was the special interest group here, what did they object to, and what was the misunderstanding about the algorithm that the journalist harbored?
Re:What the Boston School Bus Schedule Can Teach Us about AI by ForHackernews on Wednesday November 14, 2018 @02:54PM (#18453241)
Wealthy parents (who likely drive their kids to school) objected to changes in their children's school start times made as a result of trying to optimize bus schedules.
Re:What the Boston School Bus Schedule Can Teach Us about AI by philipodonnell on Wednesday November 14, 2018 @04:04PM (#18453931)
Yeah but why? Is there more traffic at those times? Does it conflict with other activities that the parents plan to do?
Re:What the Boston School Bus Schedule Can Teach Us about AI by metildaa on Wednesday November 14, 2018 @04:27PM (#18454138)
If school starts later, then they may be dropping their kid off at school at 9am or 9:30am rather than at 8am. This makes it hard to get iinto the office in a reasonable time.

Its also not quite the same problem for those of us who ride the bus, parents aren't trapped schleping kids on the bus. I'm surprised Boston Schools don't use the local mass transit system for middle & high schoolers, we've been pushing for that change in Seattle for years (all highschool students get ORCA cards finally). Why needlessly duplicate service?

Re:What the Boston School Bus Schedule Can Teach Us about AI by azeotropic on Wednesday November 14, 2018 @06:09PM (#18455091)
They do have MBTA passes for middle/high school students to take mass transit (https://www.mbta.com/fares/reduced/student-charliecards)
Re:What the Boston School Bus Schedule Can Teach Us about AI by metildaa on Wednesday November 14, 2018 @07:58PM (#18455917)
This looks to be a program for a subset of students. I'm specifically referring to giving every student a transit pass. Familiarize them early with mass transit, de-normalize driving kids to school.

Even in the well to do neighborhoods of Seattle, most of the students from upper income families are riding the bus to school after elementary. Driving your kid to school is very odd, even for the most wealthy. That being said, the private Catholic schools in Seattle are a whole different ballgame, they're singlehandedly bringing back long gone diseases as the archdiocese up here is very permissive of anti-vaxxers.

Re:What the Boston School Bus Schedule Can Teach Us about AI by azeotropic on Wednesday November 14, 2018 @10:35PM (#18456672)
The 'subset' of students is middle-school and older who are eligible for busing. If you're in elementary school or in walking distance, the school won't buy you a pass. It's opt-in and busing is the default, but from 6th grade on most kids take the T.

I don't think driving your kids to school in Boston is unreasonable. Some school buses were chronically late, delivering kids to school up to an hour after the start of the first class.

It may surprise you to learn that Boston is not Seattle. For example, the public schools here are the ones with antivaxxers and diseases you learned about playing Oregon Trail.

Re:What the Boston School Bus Schedule Can Teach Us about AI by irrational on Wednesday November 14, 2018 @07:56PM (#18455902)
Are you suggesting wealthy white kids should take public transportation?
Re:What the Boston School Bus Schedule Can Teach Us about AI by platz on Wednesday November 14, 2018 @04:49PM (#18454353)
why do you assume the opposition came from uninformed people?

Do you think they were not able to identify what is in their best interest?

Re:What the Boston School Bus Schedule Can Teach Us about AI by function_seven on Wednesday November 14, 2018 @04:56PM (#18454423)
Parent didn’t say the opposition was uninformed. Rather, the media and the broader electorate was.
Re:What the Boston School Bus Schedule Can Teach Us about AI by platz on Wednesday November 14, 2018 @04:57PM (#18454437)
ok