Re:Private by Design: How We Built Firefox Sync
by joekrill on Wednesday November 14, 2018 @05:44AM
(#18448918)
How could this even possibly be mitigated, though? At some point you have to trust something, right? This argument could extend all the way down to your OS, chipset, whatever. Unless you've built every part of your machine from scratch it's always going to rely on trusting a component you know nothing about.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Private by Design: How We Built Firefox Sync
by raffomania on Wednesday November 14, 2018 @05:51AM
(#18448951)
If you include this code in firefox itself, you can review the code and verify that the official firefox binaries use that code.
Re:Private by Design: How We Built Firefox Sync
by joekrill on Thursday November 15, 2018 @06:06AM
(#18458375)
But what about the code you run to verify the binaries? You have to trust that. Or are you reviewing every bit by hand?
Re:Private by Design: How We Built Firefox Sync
by NewEntryHN on Wednesday November 14, 2018 @05:48AM
(#18448938)
Trusting the binary is a one-time effort. Here you have to trust the JS everytime you authenticate.
Re:Private by Design: How We Built Firefox Sync
by Faark on Wednesday November 14, 2018 @07:46AM
(#18449411)
Even one-time, comparing the hash of a git commit or an installer is annoying but practically doable. I'd have no idea how to safely do something like this for a website. And I for sure ain't able to audit those ~200kb js by myself.
Re:Private by Design: How We Built Firefox Sync
by joekrill on Thursday November 15, 2018 @06:08AM
(#18458384)
But my point is you also have to trust that your underlying OS, or chipset, or even some other software on your computer doesn't have some way to thwart the entire effort. If the thing you're using the do your verification is itself compromised, then you're just as screwed.
Re:Private by Design: How We Built Firefox Sync
by IshKebab on Wednesday November 14, 2018 @10:35AM
(#18450598)
So you never update Firefox? For most users it automatically updates itself.
Re:Private by Design: How We Built Firefox Sync
by fro0116 on Wednesday November 14, 2018 @06:11AM
(#18449041)
For this use case, authenticating is a one-time effort as well, per browser. If you're authenticating again, you're almost certainly doing it on a different device/browser, at which point you'd have to verify the new browser binary anyways.