News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:John Carmack on government by cousin_it on Thursday October 28, 2010 @04:35PM (#1844834)
Apriori (that is, without knowledge of the results) communism was way less crazy-sounding that some here tend to think, because look how many smart people it attracted! Look at 60's US or at Russia circa 1900, where communism was the belief system for smart young people to "graduate" to. It had the same hipster vibe as the belief in a benevolent singularity today, only more so.
Re:John Carmack on government by hugh3 on Thursday October 28, 2010 @06:30PM (#1845226)
I wouldn't say that this means that it's a priori crazy, merely that humans have an outstanding ability to believe crazy things.

The flaws should have been apparent to anyone who understood human nature and was willing to sit down and ask the obvious questions like "What happens when X" and "But won't people Y?" They were less apparent to people who didn't want to sit down and ask these sorts of questions.

This is pretty much exactly the same level of crazy you get from anarcho-capitalists.

Re:John Carmack on government by larrywright on Thursday October 28, 2010 @11:56PM (#1846054)
The flaws should have been apparent to anyone who understood human nature and was willing to sit down and ask the obvious questions like "What happens when X" and "But won't people Y?" They were less apparent to people who didn't want to sit down and ask these sorts of questions.

This brings to mind my favorite communism story. 15 or so years ago my local newspaper ran a story about a young lady who was moving away to go work for the American Communist Party, because she had taken a trip to Cuba and seen Communism in action; it was clear to her that this was the ideal form of government for the people. That same day, the news was full of stories of people risking their lives to leave Cuba in homemade boats. It always amazed me how this girl could completely miss this.