It provides insight, yes, but a certain cost: many candidates fine this approach simply alienating, and more to the point, it upsets their thought processes (such that they don't really get a chance to shine).
As a candidate you can train for this kind of confrontational approach, of course, but I think lrm242 nailed what's most alienating about this interviewing style -- that ultimately the candidate is put into a position that's basically uncomfortable to be in, where they have to _placate_ their interlocuter according to some hidden criteria set -- and mostly they just want that particular thread to be overwith as soon as possible.
I just think we can get the same insight into candidates from different ways, where things are more on an even keel, and there's more "flow."[1] It takes more tact and creativity (and perhaps a bit more time), but it's not that hard, is more mutually enjoyable and (I think) ultimately provides a lot more insight.
[1] "flow" being of course a very important concept; e.g. in the sense of Murakami.
Because all I got from the article is that he has lots and lots of follow-up directions. I.e., that he is prepared.